A young woman's mysterious disappearance triggers a whirlwind investigation revealing betrayal and complex relationships. Her family's emotional turmoil exposes hidden dangers and vulnerabilities that emerge as they seek answers. The investigation uncovers chilling details tied to the victim's life and unearths past grievances between friends. Personal guilt complicates the journey for justice, while the aftermath highlights the community's struggle with trauma and healing after a violent crime.
Jessica Nelson's death prompted a complex investigation revealing the volatile nature of her relationships and leading to pivotal suspect identification.
Matt Kidder's unexpected involvement in the case was underscored by alarming evidence linking him to the crime scene and his violent past.
Deep dives
The Discovery of Jessica's Body
Jessica Nelson was found in her bathtub by her mother, Missy, on June 25, 2015, after she failed to arrive at work. Missy described the scene as alarming, noting the circumstances that suggested foul play, including marks on Jessica's neck and the presence of a phone cord. Investigators initially faced confusion regarding whether it was a homicide or a medical emergency due to the lack of obvious trauma. However, detectives quickly shifted their focus to treating it as a homicide, prompted by the unusual crime scene details.
Investigative Unraveling and Familial Dynamics
With Jessica's death shaking her family and friends, detectives needed to unravel the dynamics of her relationships to identify potential suspects. Jessica had a tumultuous relationship with her ex-partner, John McDowell, whom she planned to file for sole custody of their son, Dominic. Her social media presence may have inadvertently revealed to someone that she was home alone the night she died, as her final post expressed her feelings of emptiness without Dominic. The investigation also explored various acquaintances who had been in contact with Jessica, expanding the list of potential suspects.
Matt Kidder's Involvement and Investigation
Matt Kidder, a close friend of Jessica's, soon became the focus of the investigation due to suspicious phone activity and DNA evidence found at the scene. His claims about a sibling-like bond with Jessica contrasted sharply with emerging evidence that suggested otherwise. Investigators discovered Matt's presence near Jessica's home during the time of her murder and found notable injuries that coincided with her defense against an attacker. Ultimately, through mounting evidence and witness testimony, the narrative shifted to implicate Matt Kidder in Jessica's death.
The Aftermath and Trial
After Matt Kidder's arrest, detectives uncovered unsettling details about his character, including past violent behavior and disturbing content on his computer. The gathered evidence, including DNA and witness testimonies detailing his actions during and after Jessica's murder, painted a harrowing picture for the jury. In only 41 minutes of deliberation, Matt was convicted and sentenced to life in prison for Jessica's murder. The tragic loss left a lasting impact on her family, yet they found solace in supporting Dominic, ensuring he was surrounded by love and care.
When a young woman fails to show up to work, her mother rushes to her home to try to find her. What she discovers begins an investigation that leads to a suspect no one imagined. Keith Morrison reports.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode