Stan Grant, a Wiradjuri and Kamaloroi man, columnist, and distinguished professor, engages in a thought-provoking discussion about Australia’s multicultural strengths and potential weaknesses. He highlights the erosion of trust between citizens and the government, exacerbated by the housing crisis and systemic inequalities. The conversation examines the moral dissonance in political discourse and the importance of community bonds in fostering social cohesion. Grant stresses the critical need for meaningful dialogue to bridge divides and promote understanding among Australians.
The discussion highlights how Australia's multicultural diversity, while a strength, may also pose challenges to social unity and cohesion.
The speakers emphasize that addressing housing insecurity is crucial for rebuilding community bonds and restoring trust within Australian society.
Deep dives
The State of Social Cohesion
The podcast discusses the growing concern about social cohesion in Australia, highlighting how this topic has recently received unprecedented attention in the media. This concern stems from an increasing narrative that Australia is 'breaking,' particularly in the context of social unrest observed globally, such as anti-immigrant riots in the UK and deep political divides in the U.S. Comparisons are made to other nations where political systems appear to be failing due to a lack of mutual trust and democratic engagement. The speakers question whether the current social climate in Australia genuinely reflects a breakdown or if it is a harsh characterization when assessed against the more severe crises seen abroad.
Understanding 'Breaking' in Context
A central debate arises about what it means for a society to be 'breaking,' with one speaker spotlighting the difference between relative and absolute interpretations of this state. They argue that Australia might not be 'broken' in the absolute sense, where trust in institutions is entirely lost, as long-standing institutions still maintain a degree of function. The comparison draws attention to the ongoing dialogue about social cohesion, particularly its fragile nature when subjected to external pressures. By contrasting the Australian experience with other nations, the discussion emphasizes the need to assess the nuances of social cohesion and the conditions that might render a democracy vulnerable.
Social Cohesion and Trust
The conversation delves into the challenging concept of social cohesion, which is characterized as an affective state that is difficult to measure but revealing when absent. The speakers discuss how a decline in trust towards institutions and government can result in increased antagonism among citizens. They also propose that social cohesion stems from a collective sense of belonging and mutual respect, contributing to a functional democracy. The significance of community trust is underscored, indicating that when trust diminishes, so too do the vital relational bonds necessary for societal stability.
Housing as a Central Issue
The dialogue emphasizes that housing insecurity plays a crucial role in contributing to social cohesion (or lack thereof), suggesting that ongoing conversations about social services must include housing stability. The speakers discuss how the historical context of socio-economic changes and housing policies significantly affected Australian communities and their cohesion. Illustrating the stark contrast between past and present, they argue that current housing challenges create a sense of precarity that fractures community bonds and diminishes mutual trust. Furthermore, they contend that without addressing the foundational issue of housing, efforts to rebuild social cohesion may be inadequate.
One of Australia's greatest strengths has been the remarkable diversity of its multicultural society. But is this also a potential source of weakness? In this live recording at the Festival of Dangerous Ideas, Waleed Aly and Scott Stephens, along with guest Stan Grant, explore the internal and external forces that risk undermining our sense of social unity.This episode was first broadcast on 08 September 2024.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode