Backyard Housing And The Dynamics Of Collective Action
Oct 12, 2023
auto_awesome
Exploring collective action in South Africa's backyard housing problem. Discussing the living conditions and challenges of backyard dwellings. Research methodology and challenges in studying backyard housing communities. Potential progress through collective action and empowerment. Future plans and interdisciplinary challenges.
The low level of collective action in backyard dwellings in South Africa is influenced by factors such as legal status, aspirations for government-provided housing, and socioeconomic diversity within the communities.
Integrating backyard dwellers into the city and empowering them to demand support and improvements can lead to increased collective action and positive changes in their living conditions, although challenges such as legal uncertainties and limited government resources need to be overcome.
Deep dives
Inadequate housing in South Africa leads to lack of collective action
Many people in South Africa live in unsatisfactory backyard dwellings, but they do not engage in collective action to improve their living conditions. This is due to the collective action problem, where people struggle to work together to achieve a common goal, resulting in suboptimal outcomes. The dynamics of these backyard dwellings are shaped by the apartheid past, where the government promised housing for everyone. The government builds houses known as RDP houses, which are provided to the formerly disadvantaged groups. However, the recipients of these houses are asset-rich but cash-poor, so they build shacks in their backyards to earn money. The quality and size of these shacks vary, and this type of housing is the fastest growing in South Africa. Backyard dwellers come from diverse backgrounds, such as single mothers, young professionals, and working-class individuals. The tensions arise between the tenants who pay rent and the landlords who already own a house and receive government grants. Despite the pressing needs of these residents, collective action is relatively low compared to informal settlements, and the reasons for this are explored in the podcast episode.
Factors influencing collective action in backyard dwellings
The podcast episode highlights several key factors that influence the level of collective action in backyard dwellings. First, the legality of the dwelling plays a role, with backyards on public land being more likely to prompt demands and responses from the government compared to those on private land. Second, the aspiration for proper government-provided houses diverts attention and focus away from building community resilience and collective action. Third, the socioeconomic diversity within these communities creates challenges in terms of coordination and finding common goals. Finally, the presence of charismatic leaders who advocate for improvements and bridge the gap between the community and government can facilitate collective action.
Implications for increasing collective action
The podcast episode suggests that integrating backyard dwellers more fully into the city can lead to increased collective action. When residents feel more connected to the city and their rights as citizens, they are more likely to demand government support and improvements to their living conditions. However, there are challenges in terms of legal grey areas, limited government resources, and political motivations that might hinder progress. Overcoming these barriers and making incremental steps towards legalizing backyard dwellings can empower residents to demand and achieve positive changes in their lives.
Importance of interdisciplinary research
The podcast episode highlights the value of interdisciplinary research in understanding complex social issues like housing and collective action. The collaboration between political scientists, urban geographers, sociologists, and architects brings different perspectives and methodologies to the study, enriching the analysis and findings. However, interdisciplinary research also poses challenges in terms of finding suitable publication outlets and integrating various contributions within a single study, but the potential for meaningful and comprehensive understanding makes it a worthwhile endeavor.
Many people in South Africa live in very unsatisfactory so-called ‘backyard dwellings’. But few take part in collective action to improve their lot. Why not?
This puzzle centres on the broader idea known to social scientists as the ‘collective action problem’, that people often struggle to work together to achieve a common goal, leading to suboptimal outcomes. This has long been explored by scholars and is ever-present in our lives: in explanations, for example, of low voter turnout, depletion of natural resources, and foot-dragging in action to tackle climate change.
Yet collective action problems can be overcome under certain conditions – think of successful strike actions or civil rights protests, or the effective management of some local shared resources. And political scientists are naturally keen to understand what these conditions are, seeking answers by analysing group dynamics in different settings.
To explore these questions, we are joined by Dr Adam Harris, Associate Professor in Development Politics here in the UCL Department of Political Science, and also an Associated Researcher with the Centre for Social Change at the University of Johannesburg.
UCL’s Department of Political Science and School of Public Policy offers a uniquely stimulating environment for the study of all fields of politics, including international relations, political theory, human rights, public policy-making and administration. The Department is recognised for its world-class research and policy impact, ranking among the top departments in the UK on both the 2021 Research Excellence Framework and the latest Guardian rankings.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode