Marc Redfield, "Shibboleth: Judges, Derrida, Celan" (Fordham UP, 2020)
Aug 10, 2024
auto_awesome
Marc Redfield, a professor at Brown University, delves into his book, examining the concept of 'shibboleth' from biblical origins to modern implications. He discusses how language shapes community identity and boundaries, reflecting on personal experiences of exclusion. The conversation highlights Paul Celan’s poetry, exploring themes of trauma and loss through a philosophical lens, notably Jacques Derrida's insights. Redfield connects poetry to memory and political engagement, revealing the intricacies of belonging and the nuances of cultural narratives.
Marc Redfield explores the evolution of 'Shibboleth' from a biblical concept of belonging and exclusion to its implications in contemporary identity politics.
Through Paul Celan's poetry, Redfield demonstrates how language serves as both a medium for remembrance and a site of political trauma.
Deep dives
Mark Redfield's Literary Background
Mark Redfield's passion for literature, fostered from a young age, significantly shapes his scholarly pursuits. Growing up in diverse locations, including Switzerland and Brazil, he developed a profound interest in languages, especially German and French, which led him to explore comparative literature. His latest book, which centers on the biblical term 'Shibboleth', emerged from a conference paper connecting literary narratives to contemporary issues of language and identity. This intersection of personal history and scholarly inquiry drives his analysis of how the 'Shibboleth' test functions as both a linguistic measure and a metaphor for belonging in different cultures.
The Evolution of 'Shibboleth' in Language
The term 'Shibboleth' has morphed in its significance over time, particularly within the context of biblical stories and modern language. Initially used as a pronunciation test in the Book of Judges, its contemporary interpretation often signifies outdated clichés or cultural markers that define in-groups and out-groups. Redfield examines how this shift reflects broader societal changes and highlights the instability inherent in language, where meanings can be misinterpreted or lost. The dual meanings of 'Shibboleth'—both as a flowing stream and an ear of grain—epitomize the complexities of identity and belonging, revealing the ever-present tension between self and other.
Biblical Context and Literary Connections
Redfield draws parallels between the biblical story of Babel and the concept of 'Shibboleth', emphasizing the inherent instability of language. He posits that the story of Babel foreshadows the chaos present in linguistic communication, where understanding becomes fragmented yet remains tied to cultural identity. The moment of linguistic testing, exemplified by the Gileadites' requirement for Ephraimites to pronounce 'Shibboleth' correctly, reflects deeper societal dynamics of acceptance and exclusion. Through this lens, Redfield suggests that language serves not just as a barrier but also as a bridge, capable of fostering connections even as it highlights divisions.
Paul Celan's Poetry in Relation to 'Shibboleth'
Redfield delves into the works of Paul Celan, particularly focusing on the poems 'In Eins' and 'Chiboleth', revealing how they engage with themes of memory and identity. Celan’s use of the term 'Shibboleth' expands its meaning beyond mere linguistic tests to address political and historical traumas, particularly around fascism and war. The poems act as a medium for remembrance and resistance, underscoring the risks associated with language and its capacity to both include and exclude. By intertwining Celan's poetic language with the biblical narrative, Redfield illuminates the profound impact of cultural memory, urging readers to acknowledge the complex legacies embedded in language and literature.
In this episode, I speak with Marc Redfield, professor of Comparative Literature, English, and German Studies at Brown University about his most recent work, Shibboleth: Judges, Derrida, Celan, published in 2020 by Fordham University Press. In this short but intricate and dense work, Redfield investigates the “shibboleth”—the word, if it is one, and the concept—from its roots in the Book of Judges to the contemporary global regimes of technics that are defined by constantly proliferating technologies and practices of encryption, decryption, exclusion, and inclusion.
At the heart of this book is an insightful interpretation of two poems by the Romanian-Jewish, German-language poet Paul Celan. Redfield places Celan into a polyphonic dialogue with others who invoked “the” shibboleth: the French philosopher Jacques Derrida, William Faulkner, and the Colombian visual artist Doris Salcedo (whose 2007 installation at the Tate Modern, which bears the title Shibboleth, provides the cover image for the book). In doing so, Redfield pursues the track of shibboleth: a word to which no language can properly lay claim, a word that is both less and more than a word, that signifies both the epitome and ruin of border control technology, and that thus, despite its violent origin and role in the Biblical story, offers a locus of poetico-political affirmation.
Britt Edelen is a Ph.D. student in English at Duke University. He focuses on modernism and the relationship(s) between language, philosophy, and literature. You can find him on Twitter or send him an email.