The Insanity of Canadian Housing Prices (with Mike Moffatt)
Oct 11, 2024
auto_awesome
Join Mike Moffatt, a Canadian economist and senior director at the Smart Prosperity Institute, as he unpacks the chaotic landscape of Canada's housing market. He delves into the historical impact of zoning laws and urban sprawl on affordability, advocating for walkable communities. Moffatt critiques rising development charges and their consequences for homebuyers, while exploring the concept of 'drive till you qualify.' With rising prices pushing families further from city centers, he emphasizes the urgent need for sustainable urban planning.
Canada's housing crisis is exacerbated by restrictive zoning laws and the lack of diverse housing options, hindering home ownership.
Urban sprawl driven by low-density development leads to environmental issues and financial strain on municipalities, necessitating better planning.
Regulatory hurdles complicate housing construction, pushing developers toward larger projects that do not meet community needs for affordability.
Deep dives
The Housing Crisis in Canada
Canada is experiencing one of the worst housing crises globally, with skyrocketing prices making home ownership increasingly unattainable, particularly for young people. Key factors contributing to this crisis include restrictive zoning laws and inadequate provisions for missing middle housing options, which hinder the development of diverse residential types. This situation contrasts sharply with the Netherlands, which offers some lessons, albeit not always applicable to Canada’s unique context. The conversation emphasizes that while well-meaning policies aimed at controlling growth have been introduced, a holistic approach to urban planning and housing development is still missing.
Suburban Sprawl and Urban Growth Boundaries
Urban sprawl in Canadian cities involves expanding outwards into rural areas instead of increasing density in existing urban centers, exacerbating environmental concerns and financial unsustainability. This pattern is driven by incentives that favor cheaper development costs in lower-density areas, often leaving municipalities with insufficient tax revenues to support infrastructure needs. Green belts and urban growth boundaries could mitigate sprawl, but when inadequately defined or enforced, they lead to leapfrog development that undermines their intent. The discussion reveals that while municipalities restrict expansion, they simultaneously fail to create conditions conducive to building vibrant and sustainable urban neighborhoods.
Regulatory Challenges in Housing Development
Developers in Canada face significant regulatory hurdles that complicate the housing construction process, particularly restrictions like parking minimums and lot size requirements. These regulations discourage the development of smaller-scale projects, pushing developers to favor larger, profit-driven constructions such as high-rise condos, which may not fit community needs. Even when advancements, such as allowing fourplexes, are made, variations in municipal requirements can still block actual implementation. The result is a landscape where the majority of housing developments fail to meet community demands for affordable and accessible living spaces.
Induced Demand and Transit Integration
Urban planning often neglects the connection between housing and transit infrastructure, with many municipalities waiting for development to occur before implementing transit solutions. This approach fails to recognize induced demand, where the establishment of transit options should precede development to guide growth sustainably. The discussion points out that proper planning could lead to car-free communities built around transit stations, contrasting sharply with current practices that see transit retrofitted to fit sprawling developments. The missed opportunities for integrated urban growth highlight the need for coordinated planning efforts to ensure enhanced public transit accessibility.
Encouraging Sustainable Housing Solutions
Encouraging sustainable housing solutions requires a systems-level approach to dismantle the existing mindset that links growth strictly to increased traffic demands and infrastructure costs. By redefining financial responsibility for infrastructure and revising building codes, municipalities could foster conditions for more mixed-use developments and affordable housing. The conversation also emphasizes the importance of aligning immigration targets with the capacity for housing and essential services, to preserve social harmony and community growth. Ultimately, the dialogue stresses that innovative solutions are necessary to reverse current trends, making urban living more feasible and appealing to a broader demographic.
Canada's housing crisis is one of the worst in the world. But why? In this episode I talk to Mike Moffatt, Canadian economist and housing expert about what's going on in the Canadian housing market, as well as the common factors that are creating a housing crisis in almost every major city in the developed world.
Directly support the production of this podcast, and listen to every episode ad-free and sponsor-free, by subscribing to Nebula: https://nebula.tv/agenda
