

Introducing: American Criminal
6 snips Aug 27, 2025
Jeremy Schwartz, the host of American Criminal, dives into the minds of notorious serial killers Henry Lee Lucas and Ottis Toole. He examines their chilling claims of a nationwide murder spree alongside their unsettling friendship, rooted in troubled pasts. The discussion highlights the horrific case of Sandra May Dubs, revealing connections between her tragic murder and local fear. With twists and mystery, they explore how the dark side of their lives intertwines with the American experience.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Deep-Dive Crime Storytelling
- American Criminal covers crime stories in deep multi-episode seasons rather than single-episode overviews.
- The show examines criminals' motivations, investigations, and media reaction to reveal the whole story.
Fishermen Discover A Child's Head
- Two citrus farm laborers find a child's head floating in a drainage canal and call 911.
- Their discovery raises the terrifying possibility that it's connected to missing boy Adam Walsh's disappearance.
Confessions That Undermined Credibility
- Henry Lee Lucas and Otis Toole claimed hundreds of murders and then recanted repeatedly, creating massive uncertainty.
- Their conflicting confessions turned many investigations into disputes of credibility and trust.