Guest Michael Moynihan explores elite institutions' fear of firing for insubordination or incompetence. They discuss anonymous actions, controversial op-eds, protesting against silencing opposing opinions, and the disconnect between progressivism and workers. They also touch on racism, extremism, accuracy in reporting, and the power of holding the line and riding out controversies.
The lack of consequences for insubordination and incompetence in elite institutions is a result of radical ideologies infiltrating these institutions.
Modern activism often lacks sacrifice and accountability, allowing individuals to engage in cost-free civil disobedience without facing significant consequences.
There is a growing demand for leaders who enforce consequences for actions that go against norms, indicating a possible backlash against radicalism.
Deep dives
The Endangered Mean Boss: Understanding the Lack of Consequences for Insubordination and Incompetence in Today's Society
In today's society, it seems that insubordination and incompetence are no longer grounds for termination in the workplace. In the past, mean bosses would fire employees for such offenses, but now, firing is mostly handled by consultants or HR personnel. There is a growing trend of workplace compliance training or reassignment in response to transgressions, especially in elite institutions. The podcast discusses the idea of cancellation, where bosses are often the ones being fired. The host reflects on various incidents, such as the brewing scandal of Claudine Gay at Harvard and candlelight vigils protesting the president's policies. The lack of consequences for insubordination and incompetence is seen as a product of the long march through institutions, where radical ideologies have taken hold. The importance of maintaining consequences and accountability is highlighted to prevent the decline of institutions.
The Role of Radicalism and Ideological Influence in Elite Institutions
The podcast explores the influence of radical ideologies in elite institutions. It argues that these ideologies often lead to a lack of consequences for behaviors such as insubordination and incompetence, as well as the suppression of differing viewpoints. This radicalism is traced back to movements in the 1960s and 70s and the long march through institutions. The rise of cancel culture and the willingness to silence opposing opinions is seen as a consequence of this radical influence. The podcast suggests that the tireless effort to control the distribution of ideas and prevent dissent is ultimately destructive to institutions.
The Erosion of Sacrifice and Consequences in Modern Activism
The podcast highlights the lack of sacrifice and consequences in modern activism. It discusses how the courage and sacrifice of previous generations, who fought for civil rights and other causes, contrast with the actions of current activists. The focus is on the ability to engage in cost-free civil disobedience without facing any significant consequences. This trend is seen as harmful to critical thinking and intellectual growth, as it allows individuals to avoid the discomfort and challenges that come with engaging in respectful debate. The importance of instilling resilience, accountability, and sacrifice in modern activism is emphasized.
The Need for Accountability and the Backlash against Radicalism
The podcast argues for the necessity of accountability and the potential backlash against radicalism. It suggests that there is a growing hunger among the general population for leaders who are willing to enforce consequences for actions and behaviors that go against established norms and principles. The lack of action against insubordination and incompetence is seen as a betrayal of the working class and ordinary individuals who believe in fairness and accountability. The host speculates that leaders who are willing to take decisive action, such as firing employees or expelling students, may gain popularity and support as a response to the perceived tolerance of radicalism.
Dangers of Extreme Activism and Immunity to Counter Evidence
The podcast episode discusses the dangers of extreme activism, particularly in relation to the inability to have rational debates and consider counter evidence. The speaker highlights the tendency of extremists to adopt racist and intolerant behaviors, even if they view themselves as being on the side of righteousness. They draw parallels between the actions of these extremists and those who participated in disruptive movements like blocking streets or bridges. Furthermore, the speaker touches on the idea that certain experiences can only be understood through the perspective of those who directly experience them, but that this perspective is often limited to specific political ideologies.
Journalism, Fear, and the Erosion of Free Speech
The podcast examines the state of journalism and the decline of free speech. It criticizes the excessive focus on safety within newsrooms and the fear-driven narrative that inhibits open discourse. The speaker argues for the importance of journalistic bravery and the need to challenge dangerous ideas. They cite examples of journalists who faced risks in war zones and expressed controversial opinions without backing down. The loss of influential journalistic outlets, such as Vice, is attributed to the narrow-mindedness and ideological conformity that has permeated the industry. Additionally, the speaker questions the role of journalist unions in influencing editorial decisions and contends that workplace conditions should be their primary concern.
In this episode, Eli looks at why so many elite institutions are afraid of firing those that engage in insubordination or are incompetent. His guest is Michael Moynihan, co-host of the Fifth Column and America's premier plagiarism cop.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode