Neil J. Young, writer of 'Coming Out Republican: A History of the Gay Right,' discusses the contradictions and strategies of the Gay Right, emphasizing the role of whiteness and maleness in their politics. They delve into the evolution of LGBTQ Republicans' core values, response to the AIDS crisis, and adoption of 'gay family values.' The podcast explores the historical shift towards victimhood politics in the gay rights movement and the significance of Young's book.
Gay Republicans navigated tensions between visibility and privacy in advocating for LGBTQ rights.
Gay Republicans shifted focus towards 'gay family values' amidst the AIDS crisis in the '80s.
Deep dives
Origins of the Gay Right Movement in the US
The podcast delves into the early beginnings of the gay rights movement in the US, highlighting figures like Dore Leg, a member of the Madison Society and founder of One Inc. These individuals, stemming from conservative backgrounds, advocated for freedom from government surveillance and were key players in landmark legal battles protecting LGBTQ rights.
Response to the Briggs Initiative
During the Briggs Initiative proposed by John Briggs in 1978 to prevent gay individuals from teaching, gay Republicans organized to oppose the discriminatory proposition. They grappled with the balance between visibility and privacy, representing a broader debate within the LGBTQ community. The episode explores how gay Republicans navigated these tensions to advocate for their rights.
Shift Towards 'Gay Family Values'
Amidst the AIDS crisis in the '80s, the gay Republicans shifted focus towards advocating for 'gay family values', including monogamy and relationship-oriented values. Initiatives to address the epidemic and protect personal freedoms characterized this era, showcasing the community's response to societal shifts.
Evolution of Gay Republicans in Modern Politics
In the 1990s, the podcast discusses a conservative shift among gay Republicans, embodying victimhood and grievance politics that mirrored broader white male conservative ideologies. The exploration touches on figures like Milo Yiannopoulos and the mainstreaming of far-right sentiments within the LGBTQ community. The episode questions the implications of aligning with conservative movements against the interests of the broader LGBTQ community.
This week Bryan talks to writer Neil J. Young about his new book Coming Out Republican: A History of the Gay Right. They dig into some of the inherent contradictions of the Gay Right and the pillars of their political strategy and reveal how central whiteness and maleness is to their politic.