Explore the deadly consequences of poor economic decision making and the trade-off between economic benefit and human well-being. Dive into the dilemma of balancing individual and societal interests in economics. Learn about China's failed attempt at industrialization and the challenges of implementing economic policies. Discover the drawbacks of data-driven economics and the unequal distribution of benefits from globalization.
16:27
AI Summary
AI Chapters
Episode notes
auto_awesome
Podcast summary created with Snipd AI
Quick takeaways
Unintended consequences in economics can lead to deadly trade-offs between economic benefit and human well-being.
The study on the impact of smokers on the economy highlights the challenging trade-offs in economics and the need to consider both individual and societal outcomes.
Deep dives
The unexpected economic impact of smoking
A study conducted by Finnish economists revealed that smokers were less of a burden on the economy due to their shorter life spans and lower retirement pension costs. Despite being less productive and having higher healthcare expenses, smokers contributed more in taxes and had a higher net contribution to public finances compared to non-smokers. However, when the economists included the value of human life in their analysis, the results reversed. This study highlights the challenging trade-offs in economics, where what is best for individuals may not align with what is best for society.
Lessons from China's steel production debacle
In an attempt to modernize its economy, China implemented a policy to increase steel production through backyard furnaces. This approach failed as it diverted farmers' attention from farming, resulting in soil erosion and a decrease in agricultural output. The low-quality steel produced by the furnaces contributed to the Great Chinese Famine, causing the death of millions. This example emphasizes the importance of considering long-term consequences, proper investment, and the limitations of applying rigid economic theories without accounting for unpredictability and human factors.
The role of economics and the debate on globalization
There is a debate within economics about its role and the approach economists should take. Some argue for a data-driven and clinical approach that prioritizes measurable outcomes, while others suggest a more philosophical approach that considers human values and welfare. Globalization, despite its economic benefits, has resulted in winners and losers. Highly paid workers and investors benefit, while average workers face challenges and inequality. Economists like Angus Deaton emphasize the need to address the unmeasurable consequences of economic policies, such as the opioid epidemic and mass homelessness. Balancing economic theories and considering societal well-being remains a complex challenge.
If unintended consequences aren't considered, there can be a real and deadly trade-off between economic benefit and human wellbeing. Making poor policy decisions that may seem like economic opportunities can and have lead to famines, economic collapse and people losing their livelihoods, homes and lives. This is why economics is so important, and poor economic decision making can literally be fatal for millions of people.