Episode 7: How to avoid just teaching yourself

Summary

In this episode of Chalk Dust, Dr Nathaniel Swain and Rebecca Birch are joined by John Hollingsworth, co-founder of DataWorks Educational Research and co-author of Explicit Direct Instruction: The Power of the Well-Crafted, Well-Taught Lesson. Known widely as the “Purple Book,” his work has shaped how teachers worldwide think about whole-class explicit teaching.

Together, the team analyse classroom footage from maths, English, and science lessons, reflecting on how expert teachers use strategies such as “I’ll come back to you,” gestures, non-volunteer questioning, and sentence frames. John unpacks what effective checking for understanding looks like, why aiming for “80% whole-class success then corrective feedback” leads to 100% mastery, and how explicit instruction is far from “chalk and talk.”

Themes include the role of choral response in normalising mistakes, how gestures and props strengthen memory, why teachers must “work the page” rather than read slides verbatim, and the motivational power of explaining lesson importance. John shares coaching insights from working in over 25,000 classrooms, emphasising structured processing time, randomisation, and pre-planned sentence stems.

Mentioned resources and explainers

Explicit Direct Instruction (EDI), the Purple Book

Hollingsworth and Ybarra’s foundational text on well-crafted lessons and whole-class explicit teaching.

Gestures and kinesthetic strategies

Not to be confused with learning styles or VAK! Gestures are most powerful when they clearly align with meaning, such as iconic or representational movements rather than random hand-waving. Learning is supported both when students produce gestures themselves and when they observe them from teachers or peers. The benefits are particularly strong with complex or abstract material, or when students have weaker verbal memory. Gestures also help by offloading some of the cognitive load, giving learners a visual or embodied way to grasp relationships that would otherwise be carried verbally.

Sentence frames and academic language

John’s recommendation is that teachers pre-write frames with academic vocabulary to ensure students orally rehearse complete, formal responses.

Motivation and rationale

The importance of telling students why they are learning something, linking lesson content to careers, tests, or future applications.

Listen or view, and support our work

📨 Substack — sign up

🍏🎧 Apple Podcasts — like, review and follow

🎵💚 Spotify — follow and rate

📺🔔 YouTube — subscribe and like

✍️ Rebecca’s Substack — read more

✍️ Nathaniel’s Substack — read more

Takeaways

* Explicit instruction is not “chalk and talk” but highly interactive, with student responses every 20–30 seconds

* Randomisation of questioning prevents teachers from being misled by only hearing from the same few students

* Gestures and props strengthen memory, even in secondary classrooms

* Checking for understanding should move beyond surface answers, supported by sentence stems and academic vocabulary

* Explaining lesson importance supports motivation and autonomy, linking learning to tests, careers, and real-world use

* Structured processing time—pair-share, justification, complete sentences—is essential for real learning

Keywords

explicit teaching, John Hollingsworth, Rebecca Birch, Nathaniel Swain, Chalk Dust podcast, Explicit Direct Instruction, Purple Book, checking for understanding, non-volunteer questioning, I’ll come back to you, whiteboards, sentence frames, academic language, gestures, props, motivation, rationale, structured processing time, pair-share, classroom coaching, work the page, adaptive teaching

This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit chalkdust.media