Colin Burrow, an expert on Orwell's writing and his vision of socialism, joins Tom to explore the cultural conservatism and crackling violence in Orwell's works. They discuss his appeal to teenagers, the allegorical nature of 'Animal Farm,' his powerful imagery, his controversial list of suspected communists, and the portrayal of totalitarian behavior and satire in '1984'.
Orwell's writing style and simplicity resonate with teenagers; his work portrays the aspiring artist breaking free from societal constraints.
Orwell's criticism of totalitarianism was important, but his lack of constructive alternative thinking limited his effectiveness as a political writer.
Deep dives
The Appeal of George Orwell to Young People
George Orwell's direct writing style and intellectual simplicity make his work appealing to teenagers. With his use of short words and clear, hectoring adverbs, Orwell's writing conveys a sense of truth and speaks directly to young readers. Even though some of his works may seem heavy-handed or outdated, they still resonate with young readers, who appreciate Orwell's portrayal of the aspiring artist or poet breaking free from social constraints.
Orwell's Negativity as a Political Writer
Orwell was better at describing what he didn't like about the world than articulating a positive vision for its improvement. His work focused on criticizing present manifestations of socialism and large-scale control of citizens. While his descriptions of the horrors of totalitarianism were important, his lack of constructive alternative thinking limited his effectiveness as a political writer. The combination of his horror at totalitarianism and the root interest in violence and destruction in his writing suggest a preoccupation with destruction as the pathway to improvement.
Orwell's Opposition to the British Empire
Orwell's opposition to the British Empire was rooted in his experiences as a policeman in Burma in the 1920s. His essay on shooting an elephant vividly conveys the horror and self-deception involved in colonial control. However, Orwell's thinking on racial politics was not sophisticated, and his representations of the colonized Burmese people in his fiction and essays are crudely drawn. Despite this, his conviction that Britain should decolonize the empire remained consistent throughout his life.
Personal Life and Ethical Controversies
Orwell's personal life and behavior raise ethical concerns. He displayed a tendency to disconnect himself from other people, presenting himself as isolated and solitary. His actions, such as informing a government department of a list of communist sympathizers, can be seen as political betrayal and a step toward totalitarian behavior. His relationships with women, including his first wife, Eileen, were marked by infidelity and a lack of emotional support. These actions and attitudes contradict his espoused values of decency and morality.
George Orwell wasn’t afraid to speak against totalitarianism – but what was he for? Colin Burrow joins Tom to unpick the cultural conservatism and crackling violence underpinning Orwell’s writing, to reassess his vision of socialism and to figure out why teenagers love him so much.
LRB Audio
Discover the LRB's subscription podcast,Close Readings, and audiobooks: https://lrb.me/audiopod