Join Maris Kreizman, book critic, as she discusses the pitfalls of Goodreads, from negligent owners to blurred lines between readers and authors. Explore the pressure to read a certain number of books per year. Delve into the challenges of book marketing on Goodreads and the evolution of online book communities. Unravel the impact of declining criticism on book reviews and the struggles of managing diverse opinions through star ratings.
Goodreads' shift towards public reviewing introduces performative aspects that may detract from genuine reading experience.
The reliance on star ratings on platforms like Goodreads limits the depth of book discussions, highlighting the need for diverse sources of literary critique.
Deep dives
The Impact of Goodreads on Reader Reviews
Goodreads provides a platform for readers to rate and review books, often leading to a critical analysis of the texts they read. While this can enhance the reading experience, it also introduces a performative aspect that may detract from genuine enjoyment. The shift towards reviewing books on Goodreads mirrors the broader trend of turning personal experiences into public discourse, potentially affecting how readers engage with literature.
The Evolution of Book Criticism and Reader Conversations
The shift from traditional book critics to online platforms like Goodreads and book-centered social media reflects a changing landscape in book criticism. While websites like Goodreads offer a space for readers to share opinions, the absence of nuanced critique and the reliance on star ratings can limit the depth of discussion. Alternative sources such as podcasts, literary websites, and personalized reader recommendations seek to fill the gap in diverse and engaging book discussions.
Navigating Genre Criticism and Identifying Quality Critics
In the realm of genre fiction, such as sci-fi, fantasy, and romance, finding quality criticism can be challenging due to the dominance of certain review platforms. The role of critics in guiding readers towards diverse and engaging reads remains crucial, especially when considering the impact of online reviews on book selection. Engaging with reputable critics and seeking diverse perspectives can help readers navigate the often siloed world of genre fiction.
The Imperative for Amazon to Improve Goodreads
Despite criticism and toxicity within Goodreads, users may continue using the platform due to its critical mass and lack of viable alternatives. Calls for Amazon to enhance Goodreads through human moderation, fair compensation for volunteers, and improved communication with publishers highlight the potential for positive change. Balancing user experience, quality control, and author-reader interactions could revitalize Goodreads as a more trusted and engaging book review platform.
A platform where you can record what you’re reading and talk to others about what they’re reading doesn’t sound like a recipe for dystopia. But throw in a negligent billionaire conglomerate owner, optimization culture, and a competitive industry in which the line between reader and author is continually blurred… and you have a legitimate book lover’s hellscape. In other words: Goodreads! Today, I’m joined by book lover and book critic Maris Kreizman to talk about the rot at the heart of the platform, what feeds it, and whether there’s any hope of salvaging the entire enterprise. (Plus: a special bonus section where we give advice about dealing with self-imposed pressure to read X number of books a year). Also: it doesn’t matter if you’ve never gone on Goodreads in your life. If you read books, if you’re interested in the way we talk and think about books, you’re going to appreciate this episode.
Join the ranks of paid subscribers and get bonus content, access to the discussion threads, ad-free episodes, and the knowledge that you're supporting an indie pod trying to make its way in the world. If you're already a subscriber-- thank you! Join us in the discussion thread for this episode! Got a question or idea for a future episode? Let us know here.Thanks to Bookshop.org for sponsoring today's episode! Use promo code CULTURE to get 10% off your next purchase.