The Story The NHS and the changing room trans row
Jul 16, 2025
Daniel Sanderson, Scottish Political Editor for The Times, delves into the explosive NHS Fife tribunal case. He analyzes the conflict sparked by nurse Sandie Peggie's objection to sharing a changing room with transgender doctor Beth Upton. Discussions reveal the legal complexities surrounding gender identity, safety, and workplace policies while highlighting intense public interest and the broader societal implications. The conversation also addresses the recent Supreme Court ruling and its potential impact on trans rights and institutional responsibilities.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Christmas Eve Confrontation
- On Christmas Eve 2023, nurse Sandy Peggy confronted Dr. Beth Upton, a transgender woman, in a female changing room.
- This confrontation sparked a high-profile employment tribunal over single-sex spaces in the NHS.
Pronoun Dispute in Tribunal
- The tribunal ruled to avoid using gender pronouns for Beth Upton due to dispute over their gender identity.
- This reflects the legal complexity in handling pronouns in transgender-related employment cases.
Conflicting Accounts of Confrontation
- There were conflicting accounts of the confrontation: Upton said Peggy launched a barrage of insults; Peggy said her objections were more measured.
- Both sides admitted there was a confrontation involving questioning chromosomes and single-sex space concerns.