Political History of the Middle East | Timur Kuran with Javier Mejia
Sep 11, 2023
auto_awesome
Timur Kuran, a Professor of Economics and Political Science at Duke University, engages in a compelling discussion about the intertwined legacies of Islamic law and politics in the Middle East. He challenges the misconception that Islam alone obstructs freedom, illustrating how historical institutional choices significantly contribute to the region’s struggles for liberalization. Kuran argues that despite systemic repression, there are seeds of liberalization within Islamic history. He also highlights the vital role of civil society and unique economic barriers hindering progress in the region.
Timur Kuran argues that Islamic legal institutions have historically limited political freedom and economic growth across varying political regimes in the Middle East.
Despite current repression, Kuran suggests a potential for future liberalization driven by a younger, increasingly secular population challenging traditional norms.
Deep dives
Timur Koran's Academic Journey
Timur Koran, raised in Turkey and educated in the United States, developed a keen interest in the factors influencing long-term economic development and democratization from an early age. His academic path led him from economic theory to exploring the intersection of economics, political science, and religion. Koran's crisis during his graduate studies prompted him to pivot away from popular topics to pursue issues he found genuinely compelling, such as preference falsification and the political economy of religion. This shift underscored the importance of following one’s intellectual passions rather than conforming to mainstream academic trends.
Political and Economic Underdevelopment in the Middle East
Koran's book, 'Freedoms Delayed,' examines the intertwined issues of political repression and economic underdevelopment in the Middle East, challenging the perception that Islam itself is the primary cause of these problems. He highlights that, unlike other regions, the Middle East has largely failed to evolve politically, identifying a historical context where institutions hindered both economic growth and political liberalization. By analyzing the role of Islamic legal institutions and their impact on civil society, Koran reveals how the past choices in governance and social organization have contributed to the current state of repression. The region's failure to adapt and reform politically mirrors its historical trajectory of economic stagnation.
The Role of Waqfs in Weakening Civil Society
Koran emphasizes the significant role of waqfs, Islamic charitable trusts, in stifling the emergence of a robust civil society in the Middle East. Despite their economic power, waqfs were politically impotent because their structure prevented them from engaging in activities that could challenge governmental authority or contribute to social reform. The singular management of waqfs led to a lack of accountability and transparency, hindering their capacity to generate political movements or ideologies. By maintaining this weak civil society, institutions like waqfs created a political landscape ripe for autocracies to flourish.
Prospects for Future Liberalization
While Koran expresses short-term pessimism regarding immediate liberalization in the Middle East, he maintains an optimistic view about the potential for change driven by increasing disillusionment with repressive regimes. Societal shifts, particularly among younger populations rejecting traditional Islamic norms and increasingly secular views, may catalyze a reexamination of freedom in the region. Koran sees potential for liberal movements to emerge in places like Iran and Turkey, where secular and irreligious populations are growing. This transformation could foster an environment ripe for liberalization, reflecting a more intricate relationship between religious interpretations and political freedom.
Conversation with Timur Kuran, author of 'Freedoms Delayed: Political Legacies of Islamic Law in the Middle East.'
According to diverse indices of political performance, the Middle East is the world's least free region. Some believe that it is Islam that hinders liberalization. Others retort that Islam cannot be a factor because the region is no longer governed under Islamic law. This book by Timur Kuran, author of the influential Long Divergence, explores the lasting political effects of the Middle East's lengthy exposure to Islamic law. It identifies several channels through which Islamic institutions, both defunct and still active, have limited the expansion of basic freedoms under political regimes of all stripes: secular dictatorships, electoral democracies, monarchies legitimated through Islam, and theocracies. Kuran suggests that Islam's rich history carries within it the seeds of liberalization on many fronts; and that the Middle East has already established certain prerequisites for a liberal order. But there is no quick fix for the region's prevailing record of human freedoms.
---
Javier Mejia is an economist at Stanford University who specializes in the intersection of social networks and economic history. His research interests also include entrepreneurship and political economy, with a particular focus on Latin America and the Middle East. He holds a Ph.D. in Economics from Los Andes University. Mejia has previously been a Postdoctoral Associate and Lecturer at New York University-Abu Dhabi and a Visiting Scholar at the University of Bordeaux. He is also a frequent contributor to various news outlets, currently serving as an op-ed columnist for Forbes Magazine.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode