Weekend Listen: The unbelievable saga of Kaitlyn Braun, the Ontario woman who conned dozens of birth workers
Jan 25, 2025
auto_awesome
Amy Perry, a compassionate doula, shares her harrowing experience supporting Kaitlyn Braun, a young woman in crisis. They delve into an extraordinary series of fabrications, including devastating loss and medical emergencies. Amy explores the vital role doulas play in navigating emotionally charged situations like stillbirth. The discussion also highlights the complex moral dilemmas faced by caregivers when deception unravels. Throughout, they confront the emotional fallout of betrayal, grief, and resilience during an intensely traumatic time.
Kaitlyn Braun's elaborate deceit of birth workers showcases the complexities of emotional vulnerability and the ethical dilemmas faced by caregivers.
The doulas' eventual realization of the manipulation reveals profound trust issues and raises questions about accountability in client-caregiver relationships.
Deep dives
The Illusion of Support and Crisis
Caitlin Braun, a young woman facing immense distress, deceives multiple doulas while navigating a fabricated pregnancy crisis. Describing her situation as a consequence of trauma, she elicits emotional support from doulas who step in to help, believing her claims about carrying a stillborn baby after a sexual assault. The doulas, including Amy and Katie, quickly become emotionally invested in her story, providing guidance and care as Caitlin appears to face significant hurdles alone. This manipulation raises questions around the ethics of vulnerability and the responsibilities of those providing care, highlighting the fine line between truth and deception.
Escalating Medical Emergencies
Amy, one of the doulas, assists Caitlin through what she believes are labor contractions, despite the woman not being in an actual medical facility. As the situation evolves, Caitlin's condition deteriorates, leading to a series of emergencies including heavy bleeding, the necessity for a hysterectomy, and ultimately a helicopter transfer to another hospital. The doula's support becomes increasingly critical as Caitlin’s false narrative unfolds amidst real medical chaos, leaving Amy unsure of how to navigate an emotional and life-threatening scenario. The intensity of this experience reveals the deep impact of crisis on caregivers who are left grappling with an overwhelming sense of responsibility.
Unraveling the Deception
As the medical situation escalates, inconsistencies in Caitlin's story prompt Amy and Katie to question the veracity of what they have been told. They begin to investigate her claims, discovering the alarming revelation that images and details Caitlin had provided were fabricated, leading to deeper concerns about her motivations. The doulas uncover that many of the snapshots of medical crises were stock images, rather than real evidence of Caitlin's experiences. This realization strikes a profound emotional blow, leaving Amy and Katie feeling betrayed and confused about the nature of their interactions with Caitlin.
The Impact of Betrayal
The unraveling deceit profoundly affects Amy, who is emotionally drained from her commitment to support Caitlin through what she believed were genuine hardships. Initially bonded through the shared trauma of her imagined experiences, Amy feels manipulated and abandoned when confronted with the truth. This complex emotional fallout exemplifies the psychological toll on caregivers who invest deeply in their clients' struggles, only to discover that their loyalty has been exploited. The aftermath raises critical questions about trust, ethics, and the profound responsibility that care workers feel towards those they try to help.
Kaitlyn Braun, a pregnant young woman in crisis, takes dozens of birth workers through an escalating series of disasters – rape, baby loss, and even a coma. One by one, the doulas struggle to support her and grieve with her, and even save her life as they’re led down a distressing path. And then the truth comes out.
In this six-part true crime series, Sarah Treleaven untangles a complex web of lies and deception to ask who Kaitlyn really is and why she did the things that she did. Cases like these puzzle legal experts and raise intricate moral and ethical questions. This is not your average con. Kaitlyn is not your usual scammer.
Kaitlyn's Baby is Season 2 of The Con — a podcast exposing the art of deception — from CBC and the BBC World Service. Season 1 - the critically acclaimed catfishing quest, Love, Janessa, launched in January 2023.
Content warning: The latest season of The Con contains references to medical emergencies, including baby loss. We also deal with sexual assault and there is some strong language.