Julia Kemper, a data scientist at NYU who specializes in AI model outputs, and Shayne Longpre, a PhD candidate at MIT leading the Data Provenance Initiative, discuss the alarming concept of 'model collapse.' They explore how AI's reliance on AI-generated data risks homogenous and bland outputs. Kemper highlights the challenges in improving AI performance under such conditions, while Longpre emphasizes the crucial role of human curation in enhancing AI training data quality. Together, they envision a future where human creativity revitalizes AI’s capabilities.
The phenomenon of model collapse reveals that training AI on AI-generated data risks producing bland outputs and diminishing diversity.
Human involvement is essential in the AI training process to ensure the inclusion of high-quality, nuanced data that enriches AI outputs.
Deep dives
Understanding Model Collapse
Model collapse is a critical issue in the development of artificial intelligence, where the generated data begins to degrade over successive iterations. As AI systems generate data that is used to train future models, this process can lead to a homogenization of outputs, where the models become increasingly average and lack diversity. An example highlighted involves an AI's flawed attempt to provide cooking instructions, resulting in nonsensical outputs that reflect its self-referential training cycle. This phenomenon raises concerns about the AI's ability to maintain a true representation of reality as it becomes stuck in a loop of generating and training on its own increasingly bland data.
The Importance of Human Influence
The conversation emphasizes the necessity of human involvement in the training of AI models to preserve diversity and quality in data sets. Despite the rising prevalence of AI-generated content, it is crucial to ensure that human-generated data remains a dominant part of the training process to prevent blandification. Researchers advocate for curating training sets with high-quality human content, as this can incorporate valuable idiosyncrasies that enrich AI outputs. If left uncurated, the AI could reflect a skewed average, thereby losing the richness that diverse human inputs provide.
Navigating the Future of AI Data
As AI continues to evolve, there is increasing concern over the reliance on artificially generated data, which could limit the models' effectiveness and representational accuracy. The potential commodification of human content has led to a cautious approach by major AI labs, emphasizing the selection of high-quality data and the removal of biases. This shift encourages a future where AI and humans coexist in a collaborative framework, with humans guiding AI's development by ensuring that models retain their relevance and utility. Ultimately, recognizing the value of unique human traits in data creates opportunities for refining AI systems to better reflect the complexities of human experience.
Listener Gordon is worried that as AI content spreads across the web there'll be proportionally less and less human content for the AI’s to be trained on with the result their output will just get blander and blander.
He’s right to be worried, Aleks and Kevin explore the phenomena of ‘model collapse’ the inevitable breakdown of an AI to give useful results if its training data is already AI produced. Speaking to NYU data scientist Professor Julia Kempe the pair discover that training on AI generated data also means a brick wall in terms of improving AI performance.
There is hop however according to Shayne Longpre of the Data Provenance Initiative the answer is to put humans back in the loop to curate the data for the AI’s and teaching them what’s good data from bad.
Presenters: Aleks Krotoski & Kevin Fong
Producer: Peter McManus
The Artificial Human is a BBC Audio Scotland production for Radio 4
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode