The Remnant with Jonah Goldberg

Crackpot Realism

50 snips
May 15, 2025
Phil Tinline, an author and former BBC journalist, dives into his book, 'Ghosts of Iron Mountain,' exploring America's obsession with hoaxes and conspiracy theories. He shares the origins of a Vietnam-era satirical hoax that sparked intense political debate. The discussion also unveils how left and right ideologies intersect, reflecting on paranoia in politics today. Tinline traces conspiracy theories from moral panics to their current prevalence, stressing the importance of critical thinking amidst emotional narratives shaping public discourse.
Ask episode
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
INSIGHT

Satirical Roots of Iron Mountain

  • "Report from Iron Mountain" started as a satirical hoax imagining a secret government report on peace's societal impact.
  • It cleverly framed war as essential to social and economic stability, provoking debate and uncertainty.
INSIGHT

Satire Versus Conspiracy Theories

  • Satire and conspiracy theories extend ideas to absurdity; difference is satire knows it's fiction.
  • When ideas tip into "totalism," they become insupportable conspiracy theories.
ANECDOTE

C. Wright Mills' Non-Conspiratorial Critique

  • C. Wright Mills critiqued centralized power and the military-industrial complex without conspiracy paranoia.
  • Both left and right dissidents often share criticism of centralized power, despite different politics.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app