Jessica Valenti, author of 'Abortion: Our Bodies, Their Lies', and Lauren Brenzel, campaign director for a key abortion rights initiative in Florida, delve into the alarming trend of states undermining direct democracy post-Dobbs. They discuss the tactics used to stifle abortion ballot measures, including voter intimidation and misinformation campaigns. The duo highlights the emotional toll of disenfranchisement while showcasing the resilience of grassroots movements committed to protecting reproductive rights.
The use of intimidation and misinformation reflects a systematic effort to undermine direct democracy and repress voter engagement in abortion-related initiatives.
Activists emphasize that ballot initiatives not only demonstrate public support for abortion rights but also significantly influence turnout in other elections.
Deep dives
The Democratic Misdirection of Abortion Rights
The belief that returning abortion governance to the states is a democratic solution is scrutinized. This perspective overlooks the constitutional implications of overturning a long-standing precedent decided by a conservative supermajority. Critics argue that this framing ignores the reality that many voters wish to express their opinions on abortion through state ballots, yet face obstacles erected by elected officials. The juxtaposition of a so-called democratic process with the undemocratic removal of rights raises significant concerns about actual voter agency in abortion matters.
The Connection Between Voting and Abortion Rights
Activists have highlighted the intrinsic link between voting rights and abortion rights since the Dobbs decision. In the wake of attempts to push abortion rights initiatives onto state ballots, it became evident that there was considerable public support for protecting these rights. As seen in states like Ohio and Kansas, when given the chance to vote on abortion, a substantial majority choose to uphold it, which instills fear among Republican lawmakers. This correlation confirms that ballot initiatives can influence turnout for down-ballot elections, further emphasizing the stakes involved in ensuring access to abortion-related votes.
The Challenges in Florida's Initiative Environment
Florida exemplifies the significant hurdles facing efforts to place abortion rights on the ballot, particularly as activists aim for 60% approval for Amendment 4. State election officials have been accused of obstructing these efforts through rigorous scrutiny of signatures, leading to intimidation and discouragement among voters. The active involvement of state agencies in scrutinizing and undermining pro-choice initiatives reflects a broader strategy to manipulate democratic processes. Such tactics highlight the precarious nature of direct democracy in the face of systemic opposition to reproductive rights.
The Role of Misinformation and Fear Tactics
The use of misinformation and fear tactics has become pervasive in the battle over abortion rights and voting access. Alarmingly, reports indicate that law enforcement has been deployed to investigate voters' involvement in petitions, generating a chilling effect on people participating in the democratic process. The ensuing culture of fear is designed to deter voters from supporting abortion-related measures, impacting their willingness to engage in the electoral process. Such manipulative strategies not only undermine public trust but also threaten the very foundation of democracy by creating an environment of doubt and intimidation.
Republicans from Ohio to Arkansas, from South Dakota to Florida and from Nebraska to Missouri have been throwing everything at trying to keep abortion ballot measures from actually reaching voters. In this week’s Amicus - a deep look at efforts to stifle and chill direct democracy in the states, post Dobbs. Dahlia Lithwick is joined by Jessica Valenti, the author of Abortion: Our Bodies, Their Lies, and the Truths We Use to Win, and Lauren Brenzel, the campaign director for Yes on 4 in Florida, about the playbook that’s being used to threaten ballot initiatives to protect abortion rights in states around the nation.
Want more Amicus? Subscribe to Slate Plus to immediately unlock exclusive SCOTUS analysis and weekly extended episodes. Plus, you’ll access ad-free listening across all your favorite Slate podcasts. Subscribe today on Apple Podcasts by clicking “Try Free” at the top of our show page. Or, visit slate.com/amicusplus to get access wherever you listen.