The Herd with Colin Cowherd THE HERD - Hour 3 - Arch Manning got a raw deal, the Cowboys locker room, what Caleb Williams needs to do this season, Urban Meyer, Julian Edelman
Sep 4, 2025
Urban Meyer, three-time national champion and college football analyst, discusses Arch Manning's struggles and the pressure on young quarterbacks. He highlights the importance of patience in development. Julian Edelman, former Super Bowl MVP, shares insights on the NFL season and what Caleb Williams must focus on to succeed. They also delve into the dynamics of locker rooms after star player trades and the complexities of team morale, making for an engaging exploration of the interplay between college and professional football.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Quarterback Performance Is Contextual
- Urban Meyer argues quarterbacks receive too much credit and blame; team context matters more than hype.
- Arch Manning’s issues were scheme and lack of explosive supporting players, not solely his talent.
Disguised Pressure Tricks Young QBs
- Meyer praises Ohio State’s defensive disguises and simulated pressure as particularly effective.
- He shows how pressure can appear real while leaving seven players in coverage to confuse young QBs.
Veteran Leadership Trumps Coaching Alone
- Meyer warns that poor effort signals at Alabama may indicate locker-room or leadership problems.
- He stresses veteran players must assert themselves because coaches alone can't fix player buy-in.