Noam Leshem, "Edges of Care: Living and Dying in No Man's Land" (U Chicago Press, 2025)
Mar 1, 2025
auto_awesome
Noam Leshem, author of "Edges of Care: Living and Dying in No Man's Land," examines the urgent political reality of abandoned spaces across the globe. He discusses the complexities of caregiving and isolation in these no man’s lands, highlighting personal narratives from places like Gaza and Syria. Leshem challenges traditional views on abandonment by showcasing how resilient communities thrive despite neglect. The conversation explores identity, responsibility, and reimagines no man’s land as spaces of potential rather than emptiness, urging a deeper understanding of their significance.
No Man's Land symbolizes not only historical desolation but also regions of state abandonment inhabited by resilient communities fostering survival and innovation.
The personal experiences shared by Noam Leshem highlight the emotional complexities of living in politically charged No Man's Lands, emphasizing the need for recognition and care.
Deep dives
Understanding No Man's Land
The term 'No Man's Land' often carries historical imagery of desolation, typically associated with war zones. However, it can also represent spaces radically abandoned by the state, lacking sovereign care for the inhabitants. This concept extends beyond traditional battlefield examples into various parts of the world, revealing that No Man's Lands are not empty but occupied by resilient communities. In this light, No Man's Land becomes a site of survival and sometimes innovation, offering insights into how neglected areas can foster unique social and cultural dynamics.
The Biography of No Man's Land
The author reveals a deeply personal connection to the concept of No Man's Land, having grown up in an area deemed No Man's Land between Israel and Jordan. This upbringing instilled a complex understanding of the emotional and political implications of such spaces, marked by both a physical and metaphorical absence of care. Throughout the discussion, the significance of lived experiences in shaping perceptions of No Man's Lands highlights the necessity of recognizing these regions as more than mere voids. Understanding these personal narratives aids in contextualizing the ongoing struggles for recognition and care in politically charged landscapes.
The Dichotomy of Abandonment and Involvement
Gaza serves as a crucial case study, illustrating a paradox where the state exhibits both abandonment and invasive control, differing from the traditional notions of No Man's Land. The persistent Israeli blockade exemplifies a regime that exerts meticulous management over the lives of Gazans, yet simultaneously neglects essential needs, creating an environment of extreme vulnerability. This stark contrast highlights that while No Man's Land signifies a withdrawal of care, Gaza's reality depicts a sustained engagement that is often harmful. This analysis underscores how such dynamics complicate our understanding of state responsibilities in conflict zones and beyond.
Fiction, Fantasy, and Future Possibilities
The exploration of No Man's Land reveals that these spaces can also become places of radical experimentation and imagination, presenting avenues for cultural expression and community building. Historical contexts influence the narratives people create about these lands, from fantastical tales of treasures to vivid memories of survival amidst hostility. Such stories not only evoke the rich, layered experiences within these regions but also serve as reminders of the enduring impact of historical legacies on present realities. This perspective encourages a reflective approach to how we view abandoned spaces and the potential they hold for future communities.
“No man’s land” invokes stretches of barren landscape, twisted barbed wire, desolation, and the devastation of war. But this is not always the reality. According to Noam Leshem in Edges of Care: Living and Dying in No Man's Land(U Chicago Press, 2025), the term also reveals radical abandonment by the state. From the Northern Sahara to the Amazon rainforests, people around the world find themselves in places that have been stripped of sovereign care. Leshem is committed to defining these spaces and providing a more intimate understanding of this urgent political reality.
Based on nearly a decade of research in some of the world’s most challenging conflict zones, Edges of Care offers a profound account of abandoned lives and lands, and how they endure and sometimes thrive once left to fend for themselves. Leshem interrogates no man’s land as a site of radical uncaring: abandoned by a sovereign power in a relinquishment of responsibility for the space or anyone inside it. To understand the ramifications of such uncaring, Leshem takes readers through a diverse series of abandoned places, including areas in Palestine, Syria, Colombia, Sudan, and Cyprus. He shows that no man’s land is not empty of life, but almost always inhabited and, in fact, often generative of new modes of being.
Roberto Mazza is currently a visiting scholar at the Buffett Institute for Global Affairs at Northwestern University. He is the host of the Jerusalem Unplugged Podcast and to discuss and propose a book for interview can be reached at robbymazza@gmail.com. Blusky and IG: @robbyref Website: www.robertomazza.org