Todd McGowan and Ryan Angley, co-hosts of the podcast Why Theory?, delve into the cultural significance of alcohol through psychoanalytic lenses. They discuss how Hollywood's portrayal of drinking teaches us societal norms and personal identity, from the glamorization in films to the gritty undertones of film noir. The conversation touches on the subtleties of masculinity and emotional expression surrounding drinking. They also explore the impact of cultural backgrounds on personal drinking experiences, revealing the complex layers of pleasure and addiction.
The podcast explores how cultural representations of alcohol in media shape societal expectations and personal relationships with drinking.
It highlights the contrasting experiences individuals have with alcohol based on their cultural backgrounds, affecting perceptions of social interactions and masculinity.
Deep dives
The Complexity of Alcohol in Culture
Alcohol plays a significant role in cultural practices, particularly in country music, where it is often glamorized as a staple of everyday life. Many top songs incorporate references to drinking as a means of celebrating relationships or coping with emotional pain, reflecting how deeply entrenched alcohol is in social interactions. This perspective highlights the dual nature of alcohol in society; it serves both as a substance for celebration and as a mechanism for escapism. Notably, the prevalence of these themes begs the question of how different cultural backgrounds can influence one’s relationship with alcohol.
Cultural Perspectives on Drinking
Personal narratives illustrate the varied experiences with alcohol stemming from cultural backgrounds. One person's story reveals how growing up in a non-drinking culture can create apprehension towards alcohol, while another reflects on their upbringing in a society where alcohol was a rite of passage among peers. These contrasting viewpoints highlight the disparity between individual experiences and societal norms, showing how cultural acceptance or rejection shapes one’s relationship with alcohol. Such differences challenge the assumption that everyone has the same social experiences surrounding drinking.
Alcohol as a Social Connector
The notion of alcohol as a social lubricant underscores its role in facilitating connections and interactions among people. This was emphasized through examples of social settings where drinking is almost mandatory for engaging in group dynamics, raising the stakes for those who abstain. The pressure to conform can be palpable, reflecting societal expectations and the desire to fit in. Both personal and broader cultural contexts complicate the narrative, suggesting that while alcohol might foster connections, it also reinforces notions of masculinity and social status.
Psychoanalysis and the Appeal of Alcohol
Psychoanalytic theories shed light on the intricacies of individuals' relationships with alcohol, highlighting the idea of jouissance—a pursuit of enjoyment that often leads to pain. This paradox captures why individuals may engage in drinking behaviors despite knowing the potential damages involved. Through discussions of film and literature, it becomes evident that alcohol is frequently portrayed as inherently enjoyable, which complicates the understanding of its harms. The enduring attachment to alcohol is tied to its representation in culture, offering a space where individuals can grapple with pleasure and pain simultaneously.
Alcohol has been a fixture on our screens, shaping how we see and consume it. From the “bad boys” of Hollywood’s code era to the grit of film noir, have we learned to drink through the lens of our favorite characters? In this episode, Geoff unpacks these cultural cues with the hosts of Why Theory, tracing the coded messages in pop culture and his own subconscious. What have movies and TV taught us to believe about drinking — and about ourselves?
If you haven't already, listen to Episode 1 of Season 3, "Why Do I Keep Drinking?" here.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode