Dive into a lively discussion on the tactics of anti-capitalism, where strategies to smash, tame, escape, and erode capitalism are laid out. The speakers contemplate the relevance of Marxism today and delve into the stark realities of persistent poverty amid technological growth. They dissect the complexities of capitalism’s contradictions and explore how historical lessons can inform future economic models. Prepare for a thought-provoking journey through revolutionary ideas and the fragility of reform in the capitalist landscape.
The podcast discusses four distinct anti-capitalist approaches—smashing, taming, escaping, and eroding—each varying in strategy and intent against capitalism.
It critiques capitalism's inherent inequalities and environmental impacts, challenging listeners to rethink what constitutes a successful economic system.
Deep dives
Introduction to Anti-Capitalism
Anti-capitalism addresses the inherent injustices and contradictions within capitalist systems, presenting a challenge to the narrative that capitalism is the only viable economic framework. The discussion highlights Eric Olin Wright's perspectives, which outline four different approaches to being anti-capitalist: smashing, taming, escaping, and eroding capitalism. Each approach varies in target and intent, with some aiming for a complete overhaul of capitalism while others seek to mitigate its most harmful effects. Critical reflections on capitalism's negative impacts, such as growing inequality and environmental destruction, set the stage for exploring these four types of anti-capitalist strategies.
The Case Against Capitalism
Capitalism is critiqued for its duality: while it has led to increased technological innovations and improved living standards for some, it simultaneously perpetuates poverty and inequality. The conversation details how the capitalist system often generates vast wealth for a few while leaving many in precarious situations, particularly among vulnerable populations like children. This contradiction is central to the anti-capitalist argument, emphasizing that merely improving material conditions for some does not justify the systemic harms inflicted upon others. The podcast emphasizes the need to re-evaluate what constitutes a successful economic system by examining both prosperity and the prevalence of suffering.
Exploring the Four Strategies
The podcast defines and analyzes the four strategic logics of anti-capitalism: smashing, taming, escaping, and eroding capitalism. Smashing capitalism aims for radical change, believing that the system cannot be modified to benefit the majority; it advocates for a complete overhaul of capitalism. Taming capitalism tends to focus on reforming existing systems to reduce harm, while escaping capitalism emphasizes the creation of alternative systems outside of capitalist structures. Eroding capitalism signifies a gradual process that aims to undermine capitalist structures through intermittent resistance and reform, appealing to those who may not support a drastic shift but recognize the need for substantial change.
Engaging with Anti-Capitalist Perspectives
The dialogue emphasizes the importance of critical engagement with various anti-capitalist perspectives, noting that understanding the complexities and contradictions of capitalism can deepen one's analysis and activism. Listeners are encouraged to reflect on which of the four anti-capitalist strategies resonates most with their beliefs and experiences. Additionally, exploring the shadow side of each approach helps to identify potential pitfalls and challenges inherent in anti-capitalist work. By considering these perspectives and engaging in meaningful discussions, individuals can better navigate the landscape of anti-capitalism and contribute to the development of alternatives to capitalist economies.
This is a free preview of the episode "Four Ways to Be Anticapitalist." You can listen to the full episode by subscribing to our Patreon here: https://www.patreon.com/upstreampodcast
As a Patreon subscriber you'll get access to at least one bonus episode a month (usually two or three), our entire back catalog of Patreon episodes, early access to certain episodes, and other benefits like stickers and bumper stickers—depending on which tier you subscribe to. access to bi-weekly bonus episodes ranging from conversations to readings and more. Signing up for Patreon is a great way to make Upstream a weekly show, and it will also give you access to our entire back catalog of Patreon episodes along with stickers and bumper stickers at certain subscription tiers. You’ll also be helping to keep Upstream sustainable and allowing us to keep this project going.
Can capitalism be reformed? Or does it have to be smashed? This is an age-old question that has generated much discussion, debate, and disagreement on the left. In this episode of our Patreon reading series, Della joins Robert to discuss these questions within the context of a Jacobin piece written by the late Erik Olin Wright, "How to Be an Anticaptialist Today."
Can capitalism be tamed? Can it be eroded? Can it be escaped? Or must it be smashed? In exploring and answering these questions, Della and Robert cover a wide variety of topics from historical materialism, Marxism, Leninism, anarchism, prefigurative politics, and much, much more. We synthesize learnings from many of our recent episodes, explore how we've developed in our analysis since some of our older episodes, bring in explorations of history and theory, and explore what has changed and shifted in the last decade of capitalism in the West.