Yasir Qadhi When was Isra wal Miraj - An Academic Discussion
13 snips
Feb 3, 2025 Dive deep into the intriguing details of Isra wal-Mi'raj, exploring the timing and significance of this pivotal event. Scholars debate the common belief of it occurring on the 27th of Rajab, revealing a variety of opinions. Historical texts are examined, shedding light on the Prophet's spiritual journey. The podcast challenges listeners to reconsider the broader implications of this miraculous night on the Prophet's psyche and mission.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Missing Date in Early Sources
- Earliest Seerah books lack Isra and Mi'raj date, raising questions about its origin.
- Ibn Ishaq's Sira, the most authoritative source, omits the date, while later sources offer varying accounts.
Omission in Newly Found Seerah Books
- Newly discovered early Seerah books (Musa ibn Uqba, Ma'mar ibn Rashid, Suleiman ibn Tarqan) also omit Isra and Mi'raj.
- These books primarily offer skeletal outlines of events, perhaps explaining the omission.
Differing Dates in Ibn Sa'd's Tabaqat
- Ibn Sa'd's Tabaqat offers two opinions: 17th Ramadan, 18 months before Hijra, or 17th Rabi' al-Awwal, one year before.
- Neither opinion mentions Rajab, contrasting with later popular belief.