The Post War Consensus, Evangelical Longhouse, SBC Subversion, & Antioch Declaration with J.D. Hall
Mar 19, 2025
auto_awesome
In this engaging discussion, J.D. Hall, a keen observer of evangelical trends, dives into the heated debates surrounding the Post War Consensus and its implications for the Southern Baptist Convention. He critiques the ideological shifts since 2020 and highlights figures like Al Mohler and Russell Moore. Hall calls for a resurgence of boldness in Christianity while dissecting how social issues have intertwined with doctrinal principles. The conversation also touches on the changing face of evangelicalism and the growing need for accountability among leaders.
The podcast explores the notable shift within the Southern Baptist Convention as figures like Al Mohler and Russell Moore have adopted progressive ideals, impacting the church's doctrinal purity.
A critical discussion highlights the need for discernment among church leaders to confront false teachings infiltrating the SBC, emphasizing vigilance against those who superficially appear orthodox.
The conversation critiques the 'longhouse' principle as evidence of evangelical leaders capitulating to cultural pressures and calls for a reevaluation of principles aligning with biblical teachings over societal trends.
Deep dives
The Evolution of Southern Baptist Leadership
The discussion examines the shifts in leadership within the Southern Baptist Convention (SBC), particularly focusing on figures like Al Mohler and Russell Moore. Over the years, these leaders transformed from perceived conservative stalwarts to representatives of progressive ideals, leading to significant changes in beliefs and practices within the denomination. Mohler, in particular, is described as manipulating the politics of the SBC, bringing in influential individuals who furthered leftist ideologies, thus contributing to a perceived loss of doctrinal purity. This is illustrated through the rise of figures like Tabithi Anyabwile and the adoption of ideas that align more closely with progressive agendas instead of traditional conservative values.
Discernment and the Warning Against False Teachers
A critical argument is presented regarding the importance of discernment within the SBC, emphasizing that the lack of vigilance has allowed false teachings to infiltrate the church. The analogy of wolves in sheep's clothing serves to illustrate the danger of underestimating those who appear as allies while promoting heretical views. The discussion highlights the failures of church leaders to confront emerging false teachings adequately and the necessity of recognizing individuals who have previously advocated for liberal ideologies. By analyzing the historical trajectory of these leaders, it becomes clear that many were never true conservatives but rather strategic actors who shifted their positions to gain prominence within the church.
The Role of Political Expediency in Evangelicalism
Political maneuvering among evangelical leaders is critically assessed, revealing a pattern where personal ambitions overshadow doctrinal integrity. Figures like Al Mohler and Mark Dever are discussed in the context of their political affiliations and actions that reflect a disregard for biblical teachings in favor of gaining influence and maintaining power. The argument is made that genuine faithfulness to Christ is being sacrificed for political pragmatism, as leaders cozy up to various social justice agendas that contradict historical evangelical principles. This behavior not only dilutes the gospel message but also alienates many within the evangelical community who are seeking authentic leadership.
Understanding the Longhouse Principle in Evangelical Thought
The 'longhouse' principle is critiqued as a concept emerging in evangelical discourse that reflects a trend toward more egalitarian and, at times, feminist views within the church. Leaders like Russell Moore are noted for their shift from traditional complementarian views toward a perspective that allows for greater female influence in preaching. This transformation is argued to be not a mere change in opinion but rather indicative of a broader cultural capitulation among evangelical leaders to societal pressures. The discussion calls attention to the necessity of reevaluating these principles to ensure they align with biblical teachings rather than cultural trends.
The Future of Evangelicalism: Risks and Opportunities
As the landscape of evangelicalism shifts, there is a call to recognize the emerging opportunities for grassroots movements that reflect true biblical values. The discussion stresses the importance of harnessing the current climate of disillusionment with mainstream evangelical leaders to foster a more authentic and robust expression of faith. Evangelicals are encouraged to focus on evangelism and the individual relationship with Christ, rather than getting entangled in political ideologies or institutional loyalty. Ultimately, the emphasis is placed on building a faithful and courageous community that boldly proclaims the gospel amidst societal challenges rather than conforming to the pressures of contemporary culture.
What is the Post War Consensus, and why is it causing such heated debate? What does it have to do with the Antioch Declaration? And speaking of that, why has the tide in Reformed circles shifted so rapidly since 2020?
In this episode, I'll talk with J.D. Hall, who writes at Insight to Incite and has been following the evangelical subversion for over a decade. We'll also talk about Al Mohler, Russell Moore, and the intentional effort to push the SBC left. https://insighttoincite.substack.com/
2025 New Christendom Press Conference: https://www.newchristendompress.com/2025
Visit KeepwisePartners.com or call Derrick Taylor at 781-680-8000 to schedule a free consultation. https://keepwise.partners/
Talk to Joe Garrisi about managing your wealth with Backwards Planning Financial. https://www.northwesternmutual.com/financial/advisor/joe-garrisi/planning
