In this engaging discussion, J.D. Hall, a keen observer of evangelical trends, dives into the heated debates surrounding the Post War Consensus and its implications for the Southern Baptist Convention. He critiques the ideological shifts since 2020 and highlights figures like Al Mohler and Russell Moore. Hall calls for a resurgence of boldness in Christianity while dissecting how social issues have intertwined with doctrinal principles. The conversation also touches on the changing face of evangelicalism and the growing need for accountability among leaders.
01:22:17
forum Ask episode
web_stories AI Snips
view_agenda Chapters
menu_book Books
auto_awesome Transcript
info_circle Episode notes
insights INSIGHT
Mohler's Influence on SBC's Leftward Shift
Al Mohler has overseen a leftward shift in the SBC, placing figures like Russell Moore in key positions.
Despite claims of conservatism, Mohler's actions, like renewing Matthew Hall's contract after he taught critical theory, contradict his words.
question_answer ANECDOTE
Moore's Shift in Views
Russell Moore's shift in views on women's roles in the church is questioned.
Examples of Moore's past actions and statements, such as naming his son after a Democrat and admiring Hillary Clinton, are cited.
insights INSIGHT
Evangelicals and Conspiracy Theories
So-called "snooty evangelicals" often dismiss conspiracy theories due to their trust in experts and disdain for common people.
J.D. Hall argues for a supernatural conspiracy orchestrated by Satan to commandeer Christian movements.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Jay Gresham Mack's "Liberalism versus Christianity" delves into the contrasting worldviews of liberalism and Christianity, highlighting their fundamental differences in theology, ethics, and societal impact. The book examines how liberal thought has infiltrated various aspects of society, including the church, and challenges readers to critically examine their own beliefs and practices. Mack argues that liberalism's emphasis on individual autonomy and relativism undermines the core tenets of Christian faith. He offers a robust defense of traditional Christian doctrines and calls for a return to a more orthodox understanding of the faith. The book serves as a call to action for Christians to engage with the challenges of modern culture and to remain steadfast in their commitment to biblical truth. It is a significant contribution to the ongoing dialogue between faith and secularism.
Return of the Strong Gods
Nationalism, Populism, and the Future of the West
R. R. Reno
In 'Return of the Strong Gods,' R.R. Reno argues that the post-war consensus, which aimed to create an 'open society' free from the dogmas that led to World War II, is breaking down. He contends that the strong gods—powerful loyalties to nation, clan, and religion—are returning as people seek meaning and community. Reno traces the historical roots of this shift, critiquing the relativism and multiculturalism that have eroded traditional values. He advocates for a return to classic human values such as patriotism, family, and historic Christianity, warning that the absence of these strong gods could invite darker alternatives[1][4][5].
What is the Post War Consensus, and why is it causing such heated debate? What does it have to do with the Antioch Declaration? And speaking of that, why has the tide in Reformed circles shifted so rapidly since 2020?
In this episode, I'll talk with J.D. Hall, who writes at Insight to Incite and has been following the evangelical subversion for over a decade. We'll also talk about Al Mohler, Russell Moore, and the intentional effort to push the SBC left. https://insighttoincite.substack.com/
2025 New Christendom Press Conference: https://www.newchristendompress.com/2025
Visit KeepwisePartners.com or call Derrick Taylor at 781-680-8000 to schedule a free consultation. https://keepwise.partners/
Talk to Joe Garrisi about managing your wealth with Backwards Planning Financial. https://www.northwesternmutual.com/financial/advisor/joe-garrisi/planning
Hard Men Podcast 