Awais Aftab - Bridging Critical and Conceptual Psychiatry
Jul 3, 2020
auto_awesome
Awais Aftab, a psychiatrist in Cleveland and Clinical Assistant Professor at Case Western Reserve University, explores the dynamic intersection of philosophy and psychiatry. He shares insights from his journey and emphasizes the significance of 'conceptual competence' in transforming mental health care. Aftab discusses disparities in psychiatric practices between Pakistan and the US, and how critical psychiatry challenges established views, particularly regarding psychotropic medications. His interview series promotes constructive dialogues, encouraging a respectful, nuanced approach to treatment.
Awais Aftab emphasizes the role of integrating philosophy into psychiatric training to enhance understanding of mental health treatment.
He discusses his experiences with cultural stigma in psychiatry and the contrasts between mental health systems in Pakistan and the U.S.
Deep dives
Background and Stigmatization in Psychiatry
The speaker shares his journey into psychiatry, highlighting the cultural stigma surrounding the profession, particularly in Pakistan. Despite initial aspirations for a philosophical career, the influence of his physician family led him towards medicine, ultimately culminating in a focus on psychiatry. He faced significant resistance from both family and educators, who believed that successful doctors should pursue more traditional specialties rather than psychiatry, which was often viewed negatively. This background informs his current efforts to challenge stigma and advocate for change within the mental health field.
Cultural Differences in Psychiatric Training
The speaker contrasts his psychiatric training in Pakistan with his experiences in the United States, emphasizing significant cultural and systemic differences. In Pakistan, psychiatric care is under-resourced, with a low ratio of psychiatrists to patients and limited access to medications. The absence of legal frameworks for mental health care often results in chaotic treatment pathways, leading families to resort to unethical practices, such as administering medications without patient consent. This starkly differs from the U.S. system, which provides clearer guidelines and accountability in psychiatric practice.
Philosophy's Role in Mental Health Practice
The discussion highlights the importance of integrating philosophy into psychiatric training, arguing that philosophical insights can enhance clinical practice. The speaker discusses his personal philosophy studies and how they shaped his understanding of psychiatric practices, particularly concerning subjective experiences of distress. He suggests that philosophical engagement can reveal hidden conceptual frameworks that guide psychiatric diagnosis and treatment, fostering a deeper understanding among practitioners. This integration encourages a more thoughtful dialogue about the nature of mental health conditions and their treatment.
Engaging with Critical Psychiatry
The speaker’s efforts to foster conversations around critical psychiatry are exemplified through his interview series, which aims to bridge the gap between mainstream psychiatry and critical perspectives. By addressing controversial topics and varying viewpoints, the series invites robust discussions about the limitations and ethical implications of current psychiatric practices. The response from the psychiatric community has been largely positive, indicating a willingness to engage with critical ideas, albeit with some backlash. The endeavor underscores the need for humility and openness in psychiatric discourse to better address complex mental health issues.
MIA’s Justin Karter interviews psychiatrist Awais Aftab about how “conceptual competence” uses philosophy to transform psychiatry.
Awais Aftab is a psychiatrist in Cleveland, Ohio, and Clinical Assistant Professor of Psychiatry at Case Western Reserve University.
He is a member of the executive council of the Association for the Advancement of Philosophy and Psychiatry. He has been actively involved in initiatives to educate psychiatrists and trainees on the intersection of philosophy and psychiatry.
He leads the interview series Conversations in Critical Psychiatry for Psychiatric Times, which explores critical and philosophical perspectives in psychiatry and engages with prominent commentators within and outside the profession who have made meaningful criticisms of the status quo. He is also a member of the Psychiatric Times Advisory Board.
In this interview, he explores his journey into both philosophy and psychiatry and how he understands the relationship between these two disciplines. Aftab goes on to discuss how he began the critical psychiatry interview series and what he has learned from this experience and the pushback he has received. He then elaborates on how studying the philosophical issues in psychiatry, through a “conceptual competence” curriculum, could transform the doctor-patient relationship and improve mental health care.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode