Nature reasserting itself against materialism is a significant theme in That Hideous Strength, symbolized by animals attacking the bad guys.
Arthur's presence in the book represents the natural order and good governance, emphasizing the link between conforming to the natural order and becoming more human.
Deep dives
The Importance of Nature Reasserting Itself
In the podcast episode, the hosts discuss the importance of nature reasserting itself against the cold materialism depicted in the book. They highlight how the animals attacking the bad guys in the story is a satisfying and significant moment that demonstrates the return of the natural order. They emphasize that this is not a random occurrence, but a deliberate choice by the author to convey the idea of nature overcoming the dehumanizing effects of scientific pursuits.
The Misunderstood Purpose of Arthurian Legend
In the podcast, the hosts critique the host's understanding of the Arthurian legend in the book. They point out that Arthur's presence in the story is not simply a result of C.S. Lewis needing a time travel element or trying to imitate Charles Williams' style. Instead, they explain that Arthur represents the natural order and serves as a symbol of good governance for Britain. The hosts highlight the thematic parallel between conforming to the natural order and becoming more human, while dissenting from it leads to dehumanization.
The Importance of the Tau and Objective Value
The hosts discuss the concept of the Tau from C.S. Lewis' book, The Abolition of Man, and its connection to that hideous strength. They emphasize that the Tau represents the objective value and the belief in an order that transcends personal preferences. They explain that the entire narrative revolves around two contrasting ways of living, one guided by the Tau and the other attempting to undermine it. The hosts stress that conforming to the Tau leads to greater humanity, while rejecting it leads to a loss of humanity.
Promising Analysis Amidst Misunderstandings
The hosts acknowledge that while there were some inaccurate interpretations in the podcast episode, there were also moments of promising analysis. They express the need for a part two or part three to delve deeper into the positive aspects and deeper themes of that hideous strength and The Abolition of Man. They remind listeners that the podcast aims to provide a balanced perspective and a comprehensive understanding of the works of C.S. Lewis.
On this episode the guys are trying something different: Reviewing a review, specifically Gavin Ortlund's (a quintessential Made to Order Man) review of C.S. Lewis' That Hideous Strength.
And the reason? Ortlund serves as a test case, demonstrating how important the themes of the book are for believers in this hour.
