MrBallen Podcast: Strange, Dark & Mysterious Stories Fan Favorite - "Bathroom Man"
May 20, 2024
A chilling story about a woman in Cherry Hill, New Jersey encountering a mysterious man in her driveway called the bathroom man, leading to a horrific event at her home. The narrative unfolds with unsettling encounters, shocking revelations, a deadly scheme, and eventual convictions, release, and promotions.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
The Bathroom Man's First Visit
- In Cherry Hill, New Jersey, a woman was startled by a knock on her car window.
- She let the man, later called "The Bathroom Man," into her home after he asked to see the rabbi.
Carol and Fred's Life
- Carol Newlander, a successful bakery owner and rabbi's wife, lived in Cherry Hill.
- She and her husband, Fred, had built a life together over 30 years, though recently, Fred had become distant.
The Second Encounter
- Carol had a routine of bringing home cash from her bakeries, which worried Fred.
- One day, while on the phone with her daughter, a man startled her by knocking on her car window.