Asim Qureshi and Walaa Quisay, "When Only God Can See: The Faith of Muslim Political Prisoners" (Pluto Press, 2024)
Mar 2, 2025
auto_awesome
Walaa Quisay, an academic with extensive experience working with prisoners, and Asim Qureshi, research director at CAGE and advocate for detainees, dive into the harrowing yet inspiring lives of Muslim political prisoners. They explore how faith acts as a powerful form of resistance against state oppression. The discussion reveals the evolving religious practices within prisons and the moral dilemmas faced by inmates and guards alike. Quisay and Qureshi highlight the intersection of faith, identity, and community, shedding light on the profound resilience of those behind bars.
The book reveals how Muslim political prisoners utilize their faith as a powerful form of resistance against oppressive prison conditions.
The discussion highlights the influence of gender dynamics within prisons, emphasizing unique experiences faced by male and female inmates.
Deep dives
Exploring Faith and Incarceration
The discussion centers around the book 'When Only God Can See,' which examines how Muslim political prisoners experience and perceive their faith while incarcerated. The authors focus on the commonalities across different prisoners' experiences, emphasizing how their religious practices are disrupted by the conditions of their imprisonment. They initially approached the work with an intention to create a fiqh manual tailored to the context of incarceration, revealing how belief systems evolve within these confines. As the project evolved, it became clear that understanding the interplay between beliefs, practices, and the external pressures faced by the prisoners was vital.
Impact of Racialized Surveillance
The authors explore the historical context of national surveillance programs like COINTELPRO and how such policies create a racialized system that disproportionately targets Muslims during the war on terror. This historical backdrop informs the treatment of incarcerated individuals, with practices targeting their religious expressions, including their ability to pray or access religious texts. They argue that these practices reflect a broader structure of racial policing that has been operational for decades, linking contemporary actions against Muslim bodies to past injustices involving other marginalized groups. This continuity highlights recurring patterns of oppression woven into the fabric of the U.S. justice system.
Gender Dynamics in Incarceration
The podcast discusses how gender influences the treatment of prisoners in different contexts, focusing on the unique challenges faced by male and female inmates. In male-dominated environments like Guantanamo, female guards use humiliation tactics against male prisoners to exert power, while in female facilities, male guards can often enact similar forms of violence. The structural design of prisons, which often houses younger inmates with older ones, further complicates the dynamics of power and control. Such practices provide insight into how different systems of oppression manifest across various gender identities and institutional structures.
Religious Narratives and Resilience
The narratives of the prisoners often draw parallels to biblical stories, specifically that of Prophet Yusuf (Joseph), which resonate deeply with their experiences of suffering and resilience. Many prisoners relate their predicaments to Yusuf's unjust imprisonment, expressing a belief that justice will eventually be served, akin to Yusuf's eventual release. This connection serves as a source of comfort and solidarity among inmates, reinforcing their sense of identity and purpose within the oppressive environment. The discussion also touches on how these religious narratives provide a framework for understanding personal and communal struggles amidst the dehumanizing conditions of incarceration.
When Only God Can See: The Faith of Muslim Political Prisoners(Pluto Press, 2024), uncovers the unique experiences of Muslim political prisoners held in Egypt and under US custody at Guantanamo Bay and other detention black sites. This groundbreaking book explores the intricate interplay between their religious beliefs, practices of ritual purity, prayer, and modes of resistance in the face of adversity. Highlighting the experiences of these prisoners, faith is revealed to be not only a personal spiritual connection to God but also a means of contestation against prison and state authorities, reflecting larger societal struggles.
Written by Walaa Quisay, who has worked closely with prisoners in Egypt, and Asim Qureshi, with years of experience supporting detainees at Guantanamo Bay, the authors' deep connections with prisoner communities and their emphasis on the power of resistance shine through.