What is going on with MAID in Canada? Bill Gardner, Leonie Herx, & Sonu Gaind

Four percent of deaths in Canada are due to Medical Assistance in Dying (MAID).  Four percent.

The number of people who have used MAID in Canada since it was legalized in 2016 has increased year on year from about 1,000 people in the first year to over 13,000 people in 2022. California, which has a similar population size as Canada and legalized MAID around the same time, has fewer than 1000 deaths per year from MAID. 

In further contrast to the United States, MAID in Canada is almost entirely administered by a clinician, whereas in the United States patients must self administer.   To be eligible in Canada patients must have a “grievous and irremediable” condition,  including disability; they do not have to have a terminal illness with a prognosis of less than 6 months.  They could have a prognosis of years, or decades. 

A planned expansion of MAID to include people with mental illness was placed on hold until March 2024. The Canadian parliament will soon hear a report on potentially expanding MAID to “mature minors.” A recent Human Rights podcast discussed the story of a Canadian seeking MAID because he could not afford to stay housed.

Today we talk about these issues with Bill Gardner, a psychologist at the University of Ottawa who is living with cancer,  Leonie Herx, a palliative care physician at the University of Calgary, and Sonu Gand, a psychiatrist at the University of Toronto and former president of the Canadian Psychiatric Association. We talk about how Canada got to this point, including the degree to which offering MAID to anyone who is eligible has become standard practice in many places. We hear Bill Gardner's experience being told that his cancer could not be treated and immediately offered two options: palliative care or MAID. We talk about the role of palliative care and lack of access for many people living with serious illness in Canada. We go in depth about ethical issues raised by the planned expansion of MAID to people with mental illness.

Much of the criticism of the explosion of MAID in Canada is coming from people like, our guests, who feel that MAID should be an option for a select few, rather than coming from under-no-circumstance opponents. 

To many this rapid expansion will represent autonomy run amok. It is the slippery slope made real. To others MAID represents a seemingly easy and inexpensive mechanism to address failures of the system to address potentially reversible sources of suffering on a systemic level, from difficult conversations at the bedside, to meeting basic needs like housing.

For those listening to the podcast, credit to Kai for guitar on Neil Young’s Cortez the Killer (my left hand is still broken at the time of this recording). You get me with one-finger-chords on the guitar if you're watching on YouTube (best I could manage).

-@AlexSmithMD

Overview of MAID in Canada

Bill Gardner’s article about MAID in Comment Magazine https://comment.org/death-by-referral/

Bill Gardner’s articles about living with terminal cancer in Mockingbird Magazine: https://mbird.com/art/cancer-in-advent/ https://mbird.com/religion/testimony/in-the-electors-school/