

Ellie Robson on Mary Midgley on Animals
10 snips Aug 17, 2025
Discover the impactful ideas of Mary Midgley, who began her philosophical journey at 59. She critiques the belief in human superiority over animals, advocating for empathy and compassion in our relationships. The discussion revisits 1970s animal ethics, emphasizing the importance of virtues in shaping moral character. Midgley challenges historical justifications for animal cruelty, spotlighting contemporary issues in the mass meat industry. Her insights urge a reevaluation of the emotional kinship between humans and animals, enriching our understanding of moral philosophy.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
We Are Animals
- Mary Midgley insists that "we are animals," not merely like animals, and this underpins her philosophy.
- This claim rejects simple human/animal dualisms and reshapes how we think about human nature and ethics.
Dangers Of Simplifying Human Nature
- Midgley argues that treating humans as fundamentally separate from animals leads to ethical simplifications and harms animals.
- She warns that single-feature definitions of humanity (e.g. rationality) erase complexity and justify mistreatment.
The Risk Of Dualistic Thinking
- Midgley sees a human tendency to reduce and simplify concepts, which can be useful but also damaging when applied to animals.
- Over-simplified lifeboat-style dualisms distort real relationships with the natural world.