Jonah Goldberg chats with Luke Coffey, a senior fellow at the Hudson Institute specializing in Ukraine and European security. They dive into the current state of the Ukraine-Russia war following Coffey's recent trip to the region. The conversation tackles Ukrainian morale after a notable political debacle and reveals cracks within the Russian army. They also discuss the critical importance of U.S.-European alliances amidst rising skepticism and the profound implications of NATO's role in global stability.
The ongoing stalemate in the Ukraine-Russia war underscores the necessity of sustained Western support for Ukraine's innovative battlefield tactics and autonomy.
Ukrainian leaders express optimism in their engagements with U.S. officials, emphasizing their demand for security guarantees without capitulating to surrender.
The podcast highlights NATO's vital role in maintaining transatlantic alliances, essential for economic prosperity and military cooperation amidst European security challenges.
Deep dives
Current State of the Ukrainian Conflict
The war in Ukraine has resulted in a stalemate, with neither side achieving decisive victories for nearly two years. Although significant casualties have been reported on the Russian side, the lack of major front-line movement indicates that neither Ukraine nor Russia can secure a strategic advantage. Ukrainian forces remain brave and innovative in battlefield tactics, but Western support remains essential for a Ukrainian victory. This complex situation suggests that both sides might seek a negotiated settlement, acknowledging that continued fighting without substantial change is unsustainable.
Ukrainian Perspectives on Peace Negotiations
Ukrainian officials express a desire for peace but firmly reject any notions of surrender. Meetings between Ukrainian leaders and U.S. officials indicate that Ukraine's government feels optimistic after recent discussions, claiming they have not felt pressured into unfavorable agreements. The distinction between seeking peace and capitulating is clear; Ukrainians are grasping for security guarantees and sovereignty. There is a general consensus that while negotiations may occur, they need to reflect Ukraine's autonomy and territorial integrity.
U.S. Foreign Policy Dynamics
The podcast discusses how U.S. foreign policy, particularly under President Trump, influences Ukraine's situation. Ukrainian leaders appear willing to engage with Trump's administration due to an existing transactional political framework, hoping to leverage it for aid and support. This illustrates the dichotomy between immediate political gain and long-term strategic interests for the region. An ongoing concern is the unpredictability of U.S. foreign policy under potential future administrations, with calls for more definitive support from Washington to better prepare Ukraine against future threats.
Involvement of North Korean Forces
The presence of North Korean soldiers within the Russian military framework raises concerns about training and tactical development on the battlefield. Initial engagement has reportedly led to heavy casualties among North Koreans, but they are adapting to warfare techniques used in the conflict. This adaptation could create a more capable fighting force over time, contributing to fears of future North Korean military empowerment. Additionally, the potential transfer of military technology from Russia to North Korea is a cause for concern, prompting questions about the implications for regional security.
The Role of NATO and European Relations
NATO's significance is emphasized in the ongoing geopolitical discourse, as its security structure underpins economic relations between the U.S. and Europe. Despite some political rhetoric advocating for a reduced NATO role, the strategic importance of transatlantic alliances remains apparent. This alliance serves as a cornerstone for economic prosperity and military cooperation. The podcast highlights that maintaining NATO's cohesion is critical for addressing both current conflicts and future threats, illustrating that the U.S. must remain engaged with European partners.
Jonah Goldberg is joined by Luke Coffey, senior fellow at the Hudson Institute and Ukraine expert extraordinaire, to discuss his recent visit to the region and the state of the Ukraine-Russia war. Luke and Jonah debate where Ukrainians stand after the infamous Oval Office debacle, the cracks in the Russian army, and the indispensable value of close European alliances—which seem to mean little to MAGA world.
The Remnant is a production of The Dispatch, a digital media company covering politics, policy, and culture from a non-partisan, conservative perspective. To access all of The Dispatch’s offerings—including Jonah’s G-File newsletter, regular livestreams, and other members-only content—click here.
