Helen Thomas, a journalist and author known for her work on the Easey Street murders, discusses one of Melbourne's most chilling unsolved cases. She delves into the tragic story of Suzanne Armstrong and Susan Bartlett, whose brutal killings shocked the community in 1977. The podcast highlights the recent arrest of a suspect long overlooked, the evolution of forensic techniques, and the profound impact on victims' families. Thomas shares insights into how this haunting case has shaped perceptions of safety and violence against women in Melbourne.
The brutal 1977 Easey Street murders shocked Melbourne, leading to a decades-long struggle for justice amidst evolving societal fears about violence against women.
Recent advancements in DNA technology enabled the arrest of a suspect linked to the case, reigniting public interest after 47 years of investigation.
Deep dives
The Gruesome Double Homicide
In January 1977, two young women, Suzanne Armstrong and Susan Bartlett, were brutally murdered in their Easy Street home in Collingwood, with both victims suffering over 80 stab wounds. Their lives, marked by friendship and shared experiences, ended abruptly just months after they moved into their new residence. The scene was discovered two days later by a concerned neighbor who heard the cries of Suzanne's 16-month-old son, who was found unharmed. This violent crime shocked the local community and left a lasting impact on Melbourne's perception of safety.
The Investigation's Challenges
The initial police investigation faced significant hurdles as they believed they would quickly solve the case due to the apparent evidence at the crime scene. Despite focusing on a few suspects initially, including a former acquaintance of Suzanne and a neighboring crime reporter, the lack of conclusive leads caused the investigation to stall. Over the decades, advancements in DNA technology led to the exoneration of all initial suspects, leaving the case cold. As time passed, police struggled to uncover new information, ultimately delving back into files to reassess over 130 persons of interest as the public remained eager for resolution.
Recent Developments and Arrest
After 47 years without resolution, a recent breakthrough in the case resulted in the arrest of a 65-year-old suspect in Italy, identified as Peri Karumbilis, who was linked to the gruesome crime through DNA evidence. This individual's past connection to the victims, including attending the same school where Susan Bartlett taught, adds a powerful layer to the unfolding narrative. Families of the victims expressed their mix of relief and gratitude towards the police for their unwavering pursuit of justice over nearly five decades. The case has not only reignited public interest but also highlighted the broader societal fear and violence that women faced in Melbourne during that turbulent era.
If you ask a Melbourne local, almost all of them would have heard of the 1977 Easey Street murders.
In one of Victoria’s most brutal unsolved killings, two women in their 20s were stabbed dozens of times in their home on Easey Street in Collingwood.
Now, after 47 years and examining over 130 “persons of interest”, police have finally made an arrest.
Today, journalist and author of Murder on Easey St Helen Thomas, on the killings that haunted Melbourne and the suspect – known as “the boy with the knife” – that police overlooked for decades.