Brief: The CPAC Pope and the Icicle Babies (w/ Brad Onishi)
Mar 2, 2024
auto_awesome
Exploring Bishop Strickland's rise in Christian Nationalist circles post-removal by Pope Francis. CPAC analysis includes Nazi presence. Delving into gender roles, reproductive rights, and the critique of tolerance and abortion. Fatherhood and extremism intersection discussed.
The alliance between traditional Catholics and evangelicals remains strong, particularly on issues like reproductive rights where differences dissolve.
Bishop Strickland's elevation within Christian nationalism stems from his stance on core values like anti-abortion beliefs.
Deep dives
Strickland's TradCath and Evangelical Alliance Dynamics
The alliance between traditional Catholics and evangelicals remains strong, particularly on issues like reproductive rights where differences dissolve. While disagreements exist on certain aspects, a unified front prevails, especially regarding reproductive rights post-Roe v. Wade. Traditional Catholics lead the narrative on contraception and IVF ethics, guiding evangelical circles on these complex issues.
Strickland's Role in Christian Nationalism
Bishop Strickland's elevation within Christian nationalism stems from his stance on core values like anti-abortion beliefs. By aligning with figures like Bishop Fulton Sheen and Mother Teresa, Strickland reinforces narratives that resonate strongly with CPAC audiences. His speeches invoke religious authority to condemn elements like tolerance, echoing sentiments that unify different factions under a familiar moral compass.
Clerical Influence and Extremism
Strickland's association with controversial figures like Keith Fournier reveals intricate webs of influence and collaboration within conservative Catholic circles. Despite presenting an affable persona akin to Ned Flanders, his connections to individuals like Frank Pavone show a darker side. The clerical endorsement of extreme acts, such as Pavone's shocking political stunts, suggests a willingness to exploit theological premises for political gains, raising questions about the moral integrity of such alliances.
Parenting Symbolism and Clerical Absence
The symbolic fervor around pro-life agendas often divorces the reality of parenthood from the political theatrics employed by some clerics. Acts like using a dead fetus as a prop highlight a profound disconnect from the genuine challenges and responsibilities of parenting. The absence of lived parental experiences among certain advocates amplifies a detached, performative approach to advocating for pro-life causes, marking a striking contrast between symbolic gestures and the actual complexities of caregiving.
Brad Onishi of Straight White American Jesus sits down with Matthew to analyze the debut of “America’s Bishop,” Joseph Strickland, on the CPAC stage, where he blessed MAGA Christian Nationalism with his purple finery and endless torrent of anti-choice bafflegab.
Strickland—removed as Archbishop of Tyler, Texas in November by the ultra-woke Pope Francis—has hit the influencer circuit to firm up the sometimes-precarious Evangelical-Catholic alliance on the backs of women. His aw-shucks “humility” and East Texas drawl offers this reactionary movement genteel cover for its aggressive fever dreams. He is, as Onishi puts it, the Catholic Ned Flanders who conspires with Mr. Burns at night.
Butcherbox promo: Sign up today at butcherbox.com/conspirituality and use code conspirituality to choose your free offer and get $20 off.