Entitled Opinions (about Life and Literature)

The Philosophy of Inaction with Grant Dowling

Sep 19, 2025
Grant Dowling, a PhD student at Stanford, dives into the intriguing philosophy of inaction. He explores the timeless debates between Plato and Aristotle about action versus inaction, highlighting Epicurus's apolitical garden as a sanctuary. The discussion shifts to modern dilemmas like the trolley problem and the literature of refusal, featuring characters like Bartleby. Dowling also considers contemporary trends among Gen Z, including doomscrolling and the Lay Flat movement, as forms of withdrawal and collective resistance.
Ask episode
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
INSIGHT

Action Vs Contemplation Reframed

  • Modern philosophy prizes transformative action while earlier traditions prized soul-cultivation and contemplative stillness.
  • Suspended activity can reveal an inner form of action that stabilizes the world.
INSIGHT

Plato Versus Aristotle Framing

  • The Plato–Aristotle debate centers on whether theory or praxis defines the good life and political order.
  • Socratic inquiry in Plato often defers authoritative action until knowledge or virtue is secured.
ANECDOTE

Garden Retreat Versus Political Tutelage

  • Epicurus deliberately founded the Garden outside Athens and emphasized friendship and ataraxia over political life.
  • Aristotle, by contrast, tied eudaimonia to practical life and tutored Alexander the Great.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app