Pop Pantheon What Rankings Have We Gotten Wrong? Justin Bieber, Lady Gaga, Pink, & More!
Dec 4, 2025
Listeners challenge past rankings, prompting a lively debate over Britney Spears' tier standing. Haim's place in the hierarchy sparks discussion about their blend of indie rock and pop acclaim. The hosts weigh the merits of Pitbull versus Kesha, defending Pitbull's edge in global hits. Lady Gaga's status as a potential tier one artist is explored through her iconic hits. Additionally, Justin Bieber's long career and numerous top-ten singles are reconsidered for a higher ranking, along with Pink's impressive statistics supporting her tier two placement.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Annual Listener Yell-In Tradition
- Louie jokes the episode invites listeners to yell at them in a controlled way.
- He calls this annual tradition the one time the audience can angrily contribute content.
Rankings Mix Data And Cultural Judgment
- The hosts treat tier rankings as a mix of data and cultural judgment, not pure fandom.
- DJ Louie XIV insists deep dives (like Britney) are needed before changing a tier decision.
Weigh Features By Impact
- When assessing a feature, weigh whether it's a single or pivotal exposure.
- If it's not the single, Louie and Russ say a feature alone rarely changes tier status.