The unsettling disappearance of two teenage cousins during Thanksgiving sends shockwaves through their community. A violent confrontation reveals chilling truths, as a tragic home invasion leads to a complicated self-defense case. The emotional fallout unfolds, raising questions about grief and morality. Mysterious footage and courtroom drama come into play, highlighting deep divisions in the community over justice and self-defense laws. The conclusion delivers a heart-wrenching verdict, leaving families shattered and lives forever altered.
The disappearance of Nicholas and Haile on Thanksgiving triggered a desperate search by their families, ultimately revealing a tragic confrontation with Byron Smith.
Byron Smith's use of deadly force was scrutinized during the trial, raising questions about self-defense versus premeditated murder amidst community polarization.
Deep dives
The Tragic Thanksgiving Incident
On Thanksgiving Day, two teenagers, Nick and Haley, went missing, raising alarm among their families who could not reach them. The holiday, typically filled with joy, took a dark turn when it was revealed they had broken into the home of Byron Smith, a 64-year-old man who had been previously victimized by burglars. Concerns heightened as the family desperately searched for answers on why the teens failed to arrive for dinner. The devastating discovery unfolded when authorities informed their families that both Nick and Haley had been shot by Smith after entering his home.
Byron Smith's Defense and Fears
Byron Smith, feeling threatened after a string of recent burglaries, sought to protect himself and his property during what he believed to be another break-in. He armed himself and waited in his basement, convinced the intruders would pose a serious danger to his life based on his previous experiences, which included having firearms stolen from him. The Minnesota law allows homeowners to use deadly force if they feel their life is in immediate jeopardy, prompting Smith's belief that he was justified in his actions. However, the investigation raised critical questions about the extent of his fear and his subsequent actions after the shootings.
The Audio Evidence
The prosecution uncovered a chilling audio recording created by Byron Smith, who had captured the horrific incident as it occurred, including the teenagers' break-in and the fatal shots. The recording revealed dramatic moments over twelve agonizing minutes, contradicting Smith’s claims of fear, as he appeared calm and collected both before and after the shootings. His comments on the tape suggested a level of premeditation during the incident, as he specifically mentioned planning where to shoot an intruder. This evidence became central to the prosecution's argument, portraying Smith as a determined individual rather than a fearful victim protecting his home.
The Divided Community and Trial Outcome
The case quickly polarized the community of Little Falls, with some residents viewing Byron Smith as a relentless defender of his home while others labeled him a cold-blooded murderer. During the trial, the prosecution argued that his actions went beyond self-defense, ultimately charging him with first-degree murder for the killings. Even amidst the emotional turmoil for the families of the victims, the jury deliberated and ultimately found Smith guilty, resulting in a life sentence for the murders. The tragic event left lasting scars on both families, leading to profound sorrow as they navigated the aftermath and loss of their loved ones.
When two teenage cousins, Nicholas Brady and Haile Kifer, don’t show up for Thanksgiving dinner in their hometown of Little Falls, Minnesota, their families fear the worst has happened. Kate Snow reports.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode