The podcast explores George Orwell's 'Notes on Nationalism', discussing the impact of tribalism on democracy, the pathology of tribalism including obsession and indifference to reality, the influence of tribalism in media and intellectual circles, and the complexity of tribalism and the moral compass.
Tribalism is a fundamental human instinct that leads to the classification of individuals, prioritizing group interests over others, and reliance on emotional attachments rather than rationality.
Tribalism undermines liberal democracy, fosters social division, and is amplified by social media algorithms and biased media, eroding trust in authoritative sources.
Deep dives
The Pathology of Tribalism
The podcast discusses George Orwell's essay 'Notes on Nationalism,' exploring the concept of tribalism as a fundamental human instinct and its negative impact on society. Tribalism is characterized by the habit of classifying individuals and groups, assuming superiority and inferiority, and prioritizing the interests of one's own tribe over others. Tribalists are power-hungry and rely on emotional attachments to their group, rather than rationality or evidence, to justify their beliefs. The podcast also highlights how tribalism leads to an obsession with one's own group, instability in loyalty, and a disregard for objective reality.
The Destructive Effects of Tribalism
The podcast explains how tribalism undermines liberal democracy and fuels social division. Tribalist mentality leads to the abandonment of individual recognition and judgment, as people are classified solely based on their group identity. The pursuit of power and advancement for one's own tribe becomes the ultimate goal, dismissing principles of progress and contributing to an unending competition between groups. The podcast highlights the role of social media algorithms and biased media in amplifying tribalism, addicting the public to divisive narratives and eroding trust in authoritative sources.
The Principles of Tribalism
The podcast identifies the three main principles of tribalism as obsession, instability, and indifference to reality. Tribalists become obsessed with their own power unit and promote conformity and reverence for their tribe. Instability is characterized by the transferability of loyalties, sudden shifts in tribal favor, and the fear of triggering others. The tribalist indifference to reality manifests in a refusal to recognize facts contrary to their beliefs and a willingness to distort or deny the truth. The podcast emphasizes how tribalism harms society, increases division, and hampers individualism.
"Notes on Nationalism" was an essay written by George Orwell in 1945, just as World War II was ending. It caused quite a stir at the time, but most people these days have never heard of it. Nonetheless, "Notes on Nationalism" remains one of the most powerful examples of Orwell's timeless insight into human nature; in this case, focused on our instinct to gang up on each other, our instinct for tribalism.
Orwell never used the term "tribalism" himself -- he wrote this essay a generation before that term became widespread. However, I suspect his essay was a primary factor in raising awareness of the social pathology of tribalism, and his diagnosis of the problem precisely captures the liabilities of tribalism plaguing us today.
To help support Context and access bonus episodes, join me on Patreon.