Incoherence of Divine Conceptualism

The podcast episode discusses a video arguing that math proves God's existence, focusing on the concept of divine conceptualism. However, the argument presented is incoherent when examining the relationship between thoughts, propositions, and intentionality. Divine conceptualism suggests that propositions are identical to God's thoughts, but if God's thoughts are the propositions themselves, it raises questions about the nature of God's thoughts and beliefs. This lack of intentionality challenges the coherence of divine conceptualism and raises doubts about God's omniscience. Additionally, the idea that math is both discovered and invented is addressed, highlighting the contradictory nature of the argument. Whether one believes that the Mandelbrot set was designed by God or by humans, the conclusion that math was discovered does not align with the notion that it was intelligently designed or invented. Overall, the episode highlights the inconsistency and confusion in the arguments put forth in the video.