David French, an American attorney and conservative commentator, joins Skye to dissect the evolving landscape of the #MeToo movement. They discuss the stagnation of accountability in Hollywood and politics, especially within evangelical circles. The conversation also touches on the hypocrisy of perceived safety in Christian institutions and the ongoing implications of the ChurchToo movement. Additionally, they tackle a contentious Supreme Court case concerning transgender medical interventions for minors, highlighting the complexities of legal rights and societal dialogue.
The MeToo movement has witnessed a concerning decline in accountability, particularly as political figures with abuse allegations continue to evade scrutiny.
The ChurchToo movement illustrates that sexual abuse and misogyny are systemic issues within religious institutions, challenging the perception of morality in such communities.
Ongoing legal debates about transgender medical interventions reveal complex intersections between medical ethics, parental rights, and the evolving understanding of gender identity issues.
Deep dives
The Changing Landscape of Women's Movements
The discussion highlights the stark contrast between the Women's March and the Me Too movement's initial momentum in 2016 and the present political climate following Donald Trump's reelection. Eight years ago, a surge of women came forward with serious allegations against Trump, catalyzing widespread outrage and activism, exemplified by the Women's March and the rise of the Me Too movement. However, in the current landscape, despite similar allegations and findings of abuse against Trump and his associates, there is a noticeable absence of collective backlash or a revival of these movements. This shift signifies a troubling change in societal responses to issues of misogyny and abuse, reflecting a broader cultural desensitization to such matters among certain political factions.
The Toleration of Moral Corruption in Politics
The podcast points to a troubling trend where allegations and findings of sexual misconduct, traditionally serious ethical considerations, are now overlooked or dismissed when associated with prominent political figures. Instances such as the Republican National Convention featuring a speaker accused of domestic violence and Trump's own liability for sexual abuse exemplify this disregard for moral standards. Notably, the conversation discusses individuals who have faced serious allegations being nominated for high-profile positions, signaling a deeper normalization of such behaviors within political circles. This represents a significant deviation from earlier societal attitudes where accountability and moral character were deemed essential criteria for leadership roles.
The Transition from #MeToo to Church Too
The conversation shifts to the Me Too movement's evolution into the Church Too movement, emphasizing how issues of sexual abuse and misogyny previously thought confined to secular spaces are now prevalent within church institutions as well. This transition illustrates that the abuse isn't just a societal issue but one that pervades ostensibly moral communities, complicating the narrative that only liberal institutions harbor such problems. As notable institutions, including the Southern Baptist Convention and Liberty University, revealed systemic abuse, it became clear that the critique of moral failings during the Me Too movement extended beyond political affiliations. Consequently, this shift in narrative impacted the willingness of these institutions to act against abuse, reflecting an internal struggle with accountability when faced with potential institutional collapse.
Cultural Dynamics of Accountability
A key insight from the podcast is the deterioration of accountability within Christian evangelical circles regarding the abuse of power. The discussion reflects on how initially, many were responsive to the revelations of abuse, advocating for transparency and justice in the wake of high-profile scandals. However, as the realities of abuse within church structures became more evident, a pattern of defensiveness emerged, leading to a decline in the momentum that had initially ignited calls for reform. This signifies a broader cultural shift, where the urgency to address moral failings has given way to a reluctance to disrupt established power structures, indicating a deep-rooted challenge in promoting genuine accountability.
The Politics of Gender and Medical Regulation
The podcast also delves into the ongoing legal debates surrounding medical interventions related to gender identity, particularly focusing on Tennessee's ban on gender-affirming treatments for minors. This law reflects a complex battle where issues of medical ethics, parental rights, and gender discrimination converge, highlighting the vague nature of existing legal protections for transgender individuals. The discussion emphasizes how the evolving perceptions of gender treatment can significantly influence legal outcomes, especially in light of changing medical consensus around the efficacy and risks of such interventions. Additionally, the court's approach in evaluating these laws will likely reveal deeper implications for how society navigates discussions about gender, identity, and the rights of individuals facing discrimination.
The MeToo movement was a huge cultural movement—but now, many major government leaders with sexual abuse scandals under their belt seem to go under the radar—how did we get to this point? And what about the aftermath of the ChurchToo movement? David and Skye discuss this, as well as a case in the Supreme Court about Tennessee’s ban on transgender medical intervention for kids.
0:00 - Theme Song
0:17 - Show Begins
7:19 - MeToo as a Christian Ethic
12:34 - False Safety in Christian Subculture
22:48 - The Bad Patterns in the Aftermath
28:45 - Bon on Transgender Medical Intervention for Kids
The Holy Post is supported by our listeners. We may earn affiliate commissions through links listed here. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
Remember Everything You Learn from Podcasts
Save insights instantly, chat with episodes, and build lasting knowledge - all powered by AI.
