One Thing: Florida’s Book Ban Playbook: Read the Racy Parts
Oct 22, 2023
auto_awesome
CNN journalist Elle Reeve discusses Florida's new book ban law, which has sparked controversy and activism. The podcast explores the origins of book banning in Florida and the politically charged school board elections. It also highlights the impact on teachers, librarians, and young readers. Students share their perspectives on the matter and express concerns about the focus on contentious books instead of other important issues.
The new law in Florida allows books to be immediately removed from school libraries if a passage is deemed offensive when read aloud at a school board meeting, which has led to over a thousand cases of book removals and controversy fueled spectacles.
Students believe they should be allowed to form their own opinions and explore challenging themes through literature, highlighting the importance of understanding history and societal issues.
Deep dives
The Fight Over Banning Books in Florida
In Florida, a group called Moms for Liberty emerged as a response to COVID rules in public schools. Initially concerned with masking and closures, the focus shifted to the presence of pornography and objectionable ideas in school libraries. Previously, a complaint process allowed for a committee to assess a book's literary merit, but Moms for Liberty felt this was inadequate. They lobbied for a new law that allows a book to be immediately removed from libraries if a passage is deemed offensive when read aloud at a school board meeting. Critics argue that taking passages out of context can distort the true themes of the books.
The Consequences of Florida's Book Ban Law
Since the passing of the new law, over a thousand cases of book removals from school libraries have been reported in Florida. The law can be easily susceptible to abuse, as anyone can attend a school board meeting and read passages from books they find objectionable. Some groups, like Book Looks, actively seek out and publicize 'racey parts' in books. These controversy-fueled spectacles have become policy, with the support of activist groups, allies in the legislature, and even Florida Governor Ron DeSantis.
Student Perspectives on Book Bans
When speaking with students about book bans, they express confusion as to why adults fixate on books while there are other pressing issues in schools. They emphasize their ability to comprehend difficult topics such as racism and sexuality and believe they should be allowed to form their own opinions. Students argue that exploring challenging themes through literature is essential for understanding history and societal issues. Teachers are caught in the middle, removing books and facing uncertainty in what they can teach and discuss in the classroom.
A new state law in Florida is making it easier for conservative groups to get certain books removed from school libraries. It has turned school board meetings into spectacles, with parents and outside voices reading out explicit passages from books without context to argue that they should not be available to minors. In today’s episode, we explore the tactics and hear from students about how they feel about the effort by adults to control which books they have access to.
Guest: Elle Reeve, CNN Correspondent
To learn more about how CNN protects listener privacy, visit cnn.com/privacy