The Counsel of Trent
#1028 - When Liberals Were on "The Wrong Side of History"
May 5, 2025
Explore how liberal ideologies have defended historically problematic views, notably eugenics. Delve into the romanticism surrounding communism and the denial of its atrocities by liberal intellectuals. Unpack the impact of liberal social policies, especially in family law and child welfare, exposing the consequences of no-fault divorce and the sexualization of minors. This thought-provoking discussion unravels the complexities of historical advocacy and its implications on modern society.
17:01
AI Summary
AI Chapters
Episode notes
Podcast summary created with Snipd AI
Quick takeaways
- The history of eugenics highlights how liberal advocacy can sometimes defend morally indefensible practices, showing a critical moral misalignment.
- The tragic outcomes of communism demonstrate a pattern where liberals overlook the violent consequences of their idealistic beliefs, distorting historical realities.
Deep dives
Eugenics and Historical Misjudgments
The history of eugenics provides a stark example of how liberals have defended morally questionable ideas in the past. Prominent figures like Supreme Court Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes Jr. supported mandatory sterilization laws, arguing that society could prevent individuals deemed unfit from reproducing. This ideology, endorsed by early progressives including Margaret Sanger and even linked to modern policies, failed to recognize the inherent dignity of every human being. As highlighted by Planned Parenthood's 2020 apology, the harmful implications of these eugenicist beliefs are now being reevaluated, illustrating a critical shift in moral perspective.
