This podcast explores the toxic environment of an anonymous economics message board, uncovering the origins of the toxic posts and questioning if it reflects deeper issues within the field. Engineer Kyle Jensen's discovery of security flaws on the website raises concerns about identity exposure. The study reveals toxic posts from prestigious institutions, raising ethical concerns. The podcast also discusses the controversial nature of the economics job rumors site, EJMR, and the potential benefits and challenges of Argentina adopting the US dollar as its national currency.
Toxic behavior on the anonymous economics message board, Econ Job Market Rumors, was not limited to fringe individuals but originated from prestigious institutions and prominent figures in the economics profession.
The research findings sparked discussions about the need for accountability and consequences for individuals responsible for toxic posts, raising questions about the ethics and consequences of anonymous online platforms in academic circles.
Deep dives
Toxicity and Anonymity on the Econ Job Market Rumors Website
The podcast episode discusses the anonymous economics message board, Econ Job Market Rumors, and the toxic and unprofessional behavior exhibited on the site. The speakers, economist Florian Ederer and engineer Kyle Jensen, explain how they uncovered the identity of the posters on the site through an algorithmic flaw that lacked proper encryption of IP addresses. Their research revealed that the toxic posts originated from esteemed institutions and prominent figures in the field of economics, challenging the notion that these behaviors were limited to fringe individuals. The paper generated controversy and raised questions about the ethics and consequences of anonymous online platforms in academic circles.
Unmasking the Toxic Culture in Economics
Florian and Kyle's investigation of the Econ Job Market Rumors site revealed a pervasive toxic culture within the economics profession. Their statistical analysis identified universities and institutions, including prestigious ones, as sources of the toxic and unprofessional posts. The revelation sparked a strong reaction within the economics community, with concerns about professional repercussions for individuals who had posted on the site. Florian's presentation highlighted the need for the profession to address and confront the toxicity within its ranks, raising questions about freedom of speech, anonymity, and accountability in online forums.
The Impact and Aftermath of the Research Findings
Florian and his team's research findings, presented at a conference, earned significant attention and sparked discussion about the toxic speech prevalent within the economics profession. While the universities implicated in the research did not take immediate action, the revelations prompted broader conversations about the need for accountability and potential consequences for individuals responsible for toxic posts. The podcast episode delves into the tensions between anonymity and freedom of speech, as well as the ethical and social implications of online platforms that enable toxic behavior. Florian's work highlights the importance of fostering a healthier and more respectful professional environment.
Economics Job Market Rumors is a website that's half a job information Wiki, where people post about what's going on inside economics departments, and half a discussion forum, where anyone with an internet connection can ask the economics hive mind whatever they want. All anonymously.
People can talk about finding work, share rumors, and just blow off steam. And that steam can get scaldingly hot. The forum has become notorious for racist and sexist posts, often attacking specific women and people from marginalized backgrounds.
Last year, economist Florian Ederer and engineer Kyle Jensen discovered a flaw in the way the site gave anonymity to its users. The flaw made it possible to identify which universities and institutions were the sources of many of the toxic posts on the site. And helped answer a longstanding question that's dogged the economics profession: was the toxicity on EJMR the work of a bunch of fringey internet trolls, or was it a symptom of a much deeper problem within economics itself?
This episode was hosted by Mary Childs and Alexi Horowitz-Ghazi. It was produced by Willa Rubin with help from James Sneed and Sam Yellowhorse Kesler. It was edited by Keith Romer and engineered by Josh Newell. Fact-checking by Sierra Juarez. Alex Goldmark is Planet Money's executive producer.