Eoin Higgins, a journalist and author of "Owned: How Tech Billionaires on the Right Bought the Loudest Voices on the Left," delves into the ideological shifts of Glenn Greenwald and Matt Taibbi. He examines how their once leftist viewpoints have morphed into right-leaning perspectives, influenced by tech billionaires. The conversation reveals fascinating insights into the complexities of modern journalism, the impact of media ownership on public discourse, and the challenge of maintaining integrity in politically charged environments.
The podcast explores the political shift of journalists Glenn Greenwald and Matt Taibbi, revealing their alignment with right-wing narratives and figures like Elon Musk.
Audience capture within independent media is discussed as a concerning trend that compromises journalistic integrity in favor of visibility and financial benefits.
The episode critiques the intersection of journalism and conspiracy theories, illustrating how prominent figures can distort facts, impacting public discourse and truth perception.
Deep dives
Shifts in Leftist Journalism
The podcast discusses the notable shifts in the political alignment of journalists Glenn Greenwald and Matt Taibbi, who were once seen as left-leaning voices. Their respective trajectories demonstrate a transition from being critical of power to adopting right-wing perspectives, often aligning with figures such as Elon Musk and participating in platforms that amplify right-wing narratives. This evolution raises questions about their original political foundations and whether they ever held truly leftist principles. The conversation highlights the disappointment felt by former supporters who have observed this shift, emphasizing a broader concern about the integrity of left-leaning media.
Impact of Audience Capture
The podcast emphasizes the phenomenon of audience capture within the realm of independent digital media, where content creators often cater to the biases and expectations of their followers. This environment leads to a reduction in editorial oversight and fact-checking, encouraging contrarian stances that can easily gain traction online. Such dynamics create a landscape where journalistic standards may be compromised in favor of increased visibility and financial incentives. The discussion includes mentions of Barry Weiss and the allure of independent platforms that prioritize personal branding over institutional integrity.
Crisis of Ethics in Yoga Community
The episode reflects on the unexpected death of Sharath Joyce, a prominent figure in the Ashtanga yoga community, and the ensuing ethical complexities within that realm. Joyce's connection to his grandfather, Patabi Joyce, who was linked to multiple sexual assault allegations, raises important questions about complicity and accountability in spiritual lineage. The grief experienced by the global yoga community is contrasted against the harsh realities of Joyce's demanding lifestyle, which allegedly contributed to his early death. This situation underscores the tensions between idealized health narratives within yoga and the lived experiences of its practitioners.
Critical Examination of Conspiracy Narratives
The podcast covers how conspiracy theories intertwine with journalism, particularly in the context of the rise of right-wing media figures. Both Greenwald and Taibbi are cited as examples of prominent journalists who have shifted their focus, leading to the propagation of narratives that often dismiss established facts in favor of sensationalism. This shift poses challenges for public discourse, as misinformation can redefine political allegiances and blur the lines between legitimate critique and conspiracy thinking. The discussion critiques how media figures exploit these dynamics, affecting the perception of truth in journalism.
The Relationship Between Capitalism and Media
A critical analysis of how capitalism shapes media practices is evident throughout the podcast, particularly in the context of journalism's response to corporate power. The conversation reflects on the role of tech billionaires and their investments in shaping media narratives, often prioritizing profit over ethical reporting. This approach can diminish the quality of journalism, as financial motivations may lead to compromised integrity and increased bias. By examining the relationships between media, tech influence, and capitalism, the podcast highlights the ongoing struggle to maintain journalistic principles amidst evolving economic pressures.
Edward Snowden is largely only a public name thanks to Glenn Greenwald’s reporting, for which he was one of the contributors to a Pulitzer Prize-winning series for The Guardian in 2014. For a while, Matt Taibbi was considered the heir to Hunter Thompson when his gonzo journalism tore open the 2008 financial crisis and gave the public the term “vampire squids.”
Yet in more recent years, both men have swerved right: Glenn became a darling on Fox News and Taibbi was recruited by Elon Musk as one of the Twitter Files “journalists.” How did that happen? We’re joined by journalist Eoin Higgins, whose new book, Owned: How Tech Billionaires on the Right Bought the Loudest Voices on the Left, dives into the career arcs of both Greenwald and Taibbi, and how they confuse and distort right-left alignments.