Our Fake History Bonus Episode - Grisly Trophies, Evil Cowboys, and Questionable Mascots
9 snips
Dec 30, 2025 In this bonus discussion, the host dives into Buffalo Bill's surprising impact on the cowboy hero image. He unpacks the contentious history of scalping and its evolution from Indigenous practice to colonial bounty. The showman’s influence is compared to P.T. Barnum, revealing intriguing business connections. Historical reenactors are examined, highlighting the balance between authenticity and myth-making. Fun facts about Bill's legacy in Belgium and the origins of questionable mascots add a quirky twist to this captivating exploration.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Buffalo Bill Branded The Wild West
- Buffalo Bill stitched dime-novel tropes, panoramas, ethnographic displays, and real-life elements into one branded spectacle called the Wild West.
- He popularized the heroic cowboy and reshaped public images of frontier conflict into a cowboy-vs-Indian narrative.
Cowboy Rebranded As Hero
- Before the 1880s 'cowboy' was mainly an insult linked to cattle rustlers rather than heroic ranch hands.
- Buffalo Bill reclaimed and popularized the term by presenting cowboys as the premier frontier heroes in his shows.
The Cowboy‑vs‑Indian Frame Took Hold
- Buffalo Bill amplified the image of the West as principally a conflict between cowboys and Indians, even though most fighting involved the U.S. Army.
- That framing likely seeded children's games and cultural tropes of 'cowboys and Indians.'