Dr. Rachel Toles, a licensed forensic psychologist known for her work on trauma and addiction, explores the dark psychology behind infamous killers. She discusses the intersection of childhood trauma and violent behavior, analyzing notorious figures like Jeffrey Dahmer and the Menendez Brothers. Toles reveals her proprietary formula for understanding evil, debunking stereotypes about psychopathy. The conversation dives into societal influences, the nature of accountability, and why ordinary people can commit horrific acts, leaving listeners both disturbed and enlightened.
Early childhood trauma significantly shapes individuals, leading to lasting psychological effects that can manifest in violent behavior later in life.
The development of serial killers is influenced more by traumatic experiences and unstable backgrounds than by genetic predisposition or being inherently 'born bad.'
Societal reactions to violence often lack nuance, with individuals quick to label offenders as 'monsters' instead of understanding their complex backgrounds and motivations.
Cultural factors, including the glorification of violence in media, can desensitize individuals and contribute to the rationalization of violent actions.
Empathy is crucial for understanding the motivations behind violent acts, highlighting the need for effective prevention strategies by addressing perpetrators' troubled backgrounds.
Deep dives
The Impact of Early Trauma
The discussion highlights how significant early childhood events can shape individuals, particularly with respect to trauma and violence. It is suggested that pivotal experiences, such as witnessing death or experiencing abuse, can create lasting psychological effects that manifest later in life. The speaker shares personal anecdotes showing that trauma, especially in formative years between zero and three, can lead to an obsession with death and violence. This pattern is noted not only in individuals who become serial killers but broadly in those who experience similar, harrowing childhood circumstances.
The Psychological Profiles of Killers
The podcast delves into the complexities of serial killers' psyches, asserting that many are shaped by their life experiences and environments rather than being simply 'born bad.' The discussion outlines factors like unstable family backgrounds, abuse, and societal neglect that contribute to their development. It emphasizes that individuals such as Jeffrey Dahmer and Ed Gein were not just products of their genetic makeup but also of the traumatic circumstances they endured. The idea that killers are made, rather than born, is a recurrent theme.
Society's Perception of Violence
The conversation touches on how societal reactions to violence and killers often lack nuance. Many in society are quick to categorize individuals as 'monsters' or 'psychopaths' without understanding the underlying factors that led to their actions. The host argues for a more empathetic approach to understanding why these individuals commit heinous acts, viewing it through the lens of human experience rather than as detached onlookers. This perspective is crucial for fostering understanding and preventing similar tragedies.
Classification of Killers
The podcast brings attention to the complexities of classifying killers and understanding their motivations. It differentiates between serial killers, mass murderers, and individuals driven by momentary rage, suggesting that motivations can vary widely. For example, the motivations behind school shootings are discussed as distinct from those of serial killers, as societal factors play critical roles in each case. The conversation emphasizes the need for clearer definitions and a better understanding of the psychological dynamics at play in these violent acts.
Cultural Influences on Violence
The discussion explores how cultural factors, including social norms and societal expectations, influence behavior and the potential for violence. It specifically notes that cultural acceptance or glorification of violence, particularly in media, can desensitize individuals and blur moral lines. This desensitization may play a role in individuals rationalizing their violent actions. Furthermore, the conversation suggests that collective cultural values can impact how society regards killers, often elevating them to notoriety instead of addressing their actions critically.
The Role of Empathy
The podcast stresses the importance of empathy in understanding the motivations behind violent actions. It posits that when individuals fail to empathize with others, they lose sight of the shared human experience that connects everyone. The idea that empathy can foster prevention strategies is brought to the forefront, suggesting that more attention should be paid to understanding perpetrators' backgrounds and the events leading up to violence. In light of this, it encourages listeners to reflect on their capacity for empathy towards those involved in violent scenarios.
Psychology of the Female Killer
The conversation also tackles the psychological aspects of female killers, exemplified through the case of Aileen Wuornos. In discussing Wuornos, it notes how her behavioral patterns align with trauma and victimhood. The dialogue points out that female killers often have distinct motivations shaped by their experiences, including relational dynamics with male figures in their lives. This complexity complicates the perception of female killers, advocating for a better understanding of their motivations as stemming from deep-seated psychological issues.
Mental Illness and Crime
Another segment of the discussion addresses the intersections between mental illness and violent crime. It suggests that while many individuals with mental health issues do not commit violence, certain untreated conditions can contribute to tragically violent outcomes. The conversation highlights the lack of support some individuals receive and the societal stigma surrounding mental illness, which often prevents individuals from seeking help. This lack of resources exacerbates their situations, leading to potential crises if not addressed.
Exploring the Notion of Evil
The podcast raises questions about the notion of 'evil' in the context of criminal behavior. It discusses how labeling individuals as evil can mischaracterize complex human experiences, denying the multifaceted influences that lead to such actions. By addressing the labels we assign to violent individuals, the conversation encourages listeners to examine their implications on understanding and addressing criminal behavior. Ultimately, it calls for a more nuanced view that seeks to understand the deeper psychological issues at play.
Dr. Rachel Toles, a licensed forensic psychologist, delves into the psychology of criminals, addressing the motivations behind some of the world’s most notorious killers. Her expertise spans trauma, addiction, and impulse control, culminating in her upcoming U.S. theater tour, The Psychology of a Murderer. Through captivating case studies, Toles sheds light on the dark corners of human behavior.
In her show and forthcoming book, Toles examines the pathways leading ordinary people to commit extraordinary violence. She explores infamous cases, including Jeffrey Dahmer and Charles Manson, while revealing a proprietary formula for understanding evil. Her work intertwines cutting-edge psychology with gripping storytelling, leaving audiences both disturbed and enlightened.
Shermer and Toles discuss the psychology of mass murderers, causes of evil, and the fascination with true crime. They analyze infamous killers like Dahmer, the Menendez Brothers, and Manson, exploring traits like narcissism and psychopathy. Topics include experiments like Milgram’s and the Stanford Prison Study, factors driving violence, and why ordinary individuals can commit atrocities.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
