Author Alex Perez discusses the pressure for writers of color to focus on trauma-based stories, the influence of critics in the literary industry, and the challenges faced by writers from non-literary backgrounds. They also explore the class differential in publishing and the potential for future shifts in understanding and representation.
Literary awards often favor books about suffering by authors who check certain demographic boxes, making it difficult for critics to provide critical reviews.
Writers of color feel pressured to conform to a narrow framework centered around trauma and suffering in order to be recognized and published, hindering their creative freedom.
Deep dives
The Influence of Literary Prizes and Awards
The podcast episode discusses the influence of literary prizes and awards on the publishing industry, particularly with regard to books about suffering written by authors who check certain demographic boxes. The conversation highlights the way these books are often framed to make it difficult for critics to go against the overwhelming praise they receive. It is noted that these books are typically praised by white critics, while critical reviews are often written by POC writers. The conversation also touches on the historical context of diverse literature and the pressure to conform to certain narratives. Overall, the episode explores the challenges faced by writers of color and the limitations imposed by the publishing industry.
The Narrowing Scope of POC Voices
The podcast episode explores how the literary industry has created a narrow framework for writers of color, particularly those who write about POC suffering. It is discussed how these writers feel pressured to conform to this framework in order to win awards, get published, and gain recognition. The episode highlights the importance of diverse storytelling perspectives and the need for writers to have the freedom to explore topics beyond trauma and suffering. It is noted that many talented writers may be deterred from pursuing their own unique narratives due to the industry's expectations and preferences.
The Role of Institutions and Gatekeepers
The podcast episode analyzes the role of institutions, such as MFA programs and publishing houses, in shaping the literary landscape. It is suggested that these institutions have undergone significant changes in recent years, with a shift towards promoting certain narratives and limiting the range of acceptable storytelling. The episode discusses the impact of the pressure to diversify, both within these institutions and in response to societal conversations about race and social justice. The conversation delves into the challenges faced by writers who want to deviate from established narratives and the discomfort that editors and agents may have when encountering stories that challenge their preconceived notions.
Class Dynamics and the Need for Inclusivity
The podcast episode highlights the class dynamics at play within the literary industry, noting that it often favors individuals who come from privileged backgrounds. It is discussed how financial barriers, such as the cost of publishing programs, limit access to opportunities and contribute to the lack of diversity in the industry. The conversation emphasizes the importance of making publishing a more inclusive space, where writers from diverse backgrounds and experiences can find support and have their stories heard. The episode concludes with a discussion on the potential for change and the need to challenge existing power structures within the industry.