Dharna Noor, a climate reporter at Guardian US and former Boston Globe climate producer, breaks down the outcomes of COP29. She shares her firsthand experiences from the conference, highlighting the central themes of climate finance and the complex negotiations between developed and developing nations. The intense discussions around a proposed $300 billion annual contribution are revealed, along with insights into the influence of the fossil fuel industry. Dharna emphasizes the critical role of quality journalism in shaping climate discourse and action.
COP29 highlighted a significant commitment for developed nations to provide $300 billion annually in climate finance by 2035, yet it fell short of the $1.3 trillion requested, raising concerns over adequacy.
The conference underscored the complexities of climate negotiations, particularly the tension between the Global North and South regarding financial commitments and accountability for funding.
Deep dives
Key Stakes of COP29
COP29 marked a pivotal moment as negotiators focused primarily on climate finance, particularly the commitment of wealthy nations to support developing countries in their climate action plans. This conference represented a shift towards recognizing the financial aspects of climate action, with a significant emphasis on determining how much funding wealthier nations would provide for adaptation and mitigation efforts. The complexity of negotiations was heightened by the historical context of underfunded climate commitments and the urgent need for action, making it a contentious and high-stakes event. The discussions underscored the blurred lines between financial commitments and political will, revealing the challenges in achieving a consensus among nations with varying economic interests.
Outcomes of the Final Agreement
The final agreement at COP29 included a significant, though contentious, commitment for developed nations to provide $300 billion annually in climate finance by 2035, a notable increase from previous commitments. However, this amount fell short of the $1.3 trillion requested by developing countries, raising concerns about its adequacy and the ability to meet the growing climate crisis. The agreement's non-binding nature meant that while it established a framework for future funding, enforceability remained an open question, with distrust prevalent among developing nations regarding the commitment of wealthier countries. Key discussions highlighted the need for clarity on the source and accountability of these funds, which could affect the effectiveness of climate actions worldwide.
Challenges of Climate Finance
Throughout COP29, the complexities surrounding climate finance were brought to the forefront, with distinct discussions about adaptation, mitigation, and the newly established loss and damage fund. While adaptation and mitigation funding were prioritized, the separate issue of funding for loss and damage, aimed at addressing the impacts already faced by vulnerable nations, created added layers of contention among negotiators. The need for public sector funding, in contrast to the predominance of private finance, was emphasized by representatives from developing nations who highlighted the challenges in securing resources for necessary climate adaptations. As negotiations unfolded, a critical concern emerged about the mechanisms to ensure that the agreed-upon funds would genuinely reach the communities in need, particularly in the context of existing debts faced by these nations.
Skepticism and Future Implications
Reflections on the COP29 outcomes indicated a widespread skepticism about the likelihood of countries meeting their financial commitments, especially given the history of unmet targets in previous agreements. Observers noted that the upcoming political dynamics, particularly potential shifts in governmental leadership in key countries, could hinder progress towards attaining these goals. The overall distrust among developing nations regarding the efficacy and reliability of the negotiation process prompted calls for reform in international climate agreements to enhance accountability. As COP30 approaches, the fallout from COP29 raises critical questions about the efficacy of global climate negotiations and the urgent need for a more equitable and transparent funding system.
COP29 is over. A new agreement has been struck. So what the hell happened?
Climate reporter Dharna Noor is here to explain. She was on the ground during the conference to cover it all and she's on the show this week to deep dive into the results and what it means for global climate action. Dharna discusses the complexities and stakes surrounding COP29, how the central theme of climate finance shaped the conference, and the key takeaways of the final agreement. We also discuss the tension between the Global North and South during negotations, the wild events that unfolded during negotiations, and the importance of good reporting and press coverage during these multilateral discussions.
Dharna Noor is a fossil fuels and climate reporter at Guardian US. Prior to that, Dharna was the Boston Globe's climate producer, worked as a staff writer at Earther, where she also co-produced a season of the podcast Drilled on the fossil fuel industry's influence on education.
Check out all of The Guardians's COP29 reporting here.
As always, follow us @climatepod on Twitter and email us at theclimatepod@gmail.com. Our music is "Gotta Get Up" by The Passion Hifi, check out his music at thepassionhifi.com. Rate, review and subscribe to this podcast on iTunes, Spotify, Stitcher, and more! Subscribe to our YouTube channel! Join our Facebook group.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode