Where does modern conservatism leave Trump ahead of Nov. election?
Sep 27, 2024
auto_awesome
David French, an Opinion Columnist at The New York Times and known for his conservative insights, joins Jonah Goldberg, Editor-in-Chief at The Dispatch, to dissect the evolving landscape of conservatism amidst Trump's influence. They highlight the split within the GOP, featuring Liz Cheney's surprising endorsements of Democrats. The duo explores how Trump and Kamala Harris are targeting similar voter bases. Additionally, they delve into the escalating Israel-Hamas conflict and its global ramifications, emphasizing the need for cohesive U.S. foreign policy.
The podcast emphasizes the complexity within modern conservatism, highlighting the divide between traditional Republicans and pro-Trump supporters amid election dynamics.
A significant theme discussed is the potential impact of the upcoming election outcomes on the future direction of the Republican Party and conservatism itself.
Deep dives
The Evolving Definition of Conservatism
The podcast addresses the complexities of identifying what it means to be a conservative in contemporary American politics. Discussions revolve around whether conservatism is synonymous with Republicanism, especially in light of figures like Liz Cheney, who has publicly denounced Donald Trump but still identifies as a conservative. This raises questions about the diversity of beliefs within the conservative movement and how certain factions have shifted, particularly among those who oppose Trump. The speakers reflect on their personal voting histories, highlighting how party allegiance can shape perceptions of political identity.
The Threat of Trumpism
The conversation highlights the existential threat that Donald Trump is perceived to pose to American democracy, as articulated by Liz Cheney and others. They discuss the implications of Trump's potential re-election, emphasizing that many long-time Republicans feel compelled to support Democratic candidates to counter his influence. The critical sentiment is shared among some conservative figures that a vote against Trump is necessary to preserve the integrity of the Republican Party. The discourse focuses on the urgent need to mobilize against Trump to prevent what they view as a significant danger to the republican system.
Impact of Potential Election Outcomes
The potential outcomes of the upcoming election are analyzed in depth, with varying scenarios discussed concerning what a Trump win or loss could mean for conservatism in America. A significant Trump loss is seen as an opportunity for a resurgence of traditional conservative values, which may open the door to a moderated form of populism. Conversely, a blowout victory for Trump could entrench MAGA ideology, while a narrow win would still be celebrated by his supporters despite any potential shortcomings. This examination of election repercussions reflects broader anxieties about the future direction of the Republican Party and conservatism as a whole.
Comparative Analysis of Policy Positions
The podcast draws parallels between the policy proposals of Kamala Harris and Donald Trump, noting that they sometimes appear strikingly similar despite the perception of each candidate as an existential threat to the country. The discourse explores how both candidates are attempting to appeal to the median voter, often employing similar rhetoric in their bids for election. Key distinctions are made in areas like foreign policy, especially regarding relations with Ukraine, highlighting deeper ideological divides that transcend mere campaign promises. This comparison points to a growing concern that entrenched partisanship might overshadow genuine policy differences, complicating voter decisions.
The “never Trump” sentiment has long existed in the media. But there is a growing divide between what it means to be conservative, Republican, and pro-Trumper — they are not all one and the same. Established Republicans, including Liz Cheney, endorsed Kamala Harris in this election due to concerns that Trump has taken over the GOP. This week’s Left, Right, and Center panel consists of three conservatives breaking down what it means to be a “never Trump” Republican.
Both Trump and Harris have campaigned on similar policies when it comes to the economy, immigration, and gun ownership. Both have focused on winning over the same swing and Centerist voters. But is this middle ground a good thing? Is it the start of bridging party divides?
While the Israel-Hamas conflict continues in Gaza, there have been a number of strikes in Lebanon targeting Hezbollah. This has gained international attention, as worries rise of a full-fledged war. Can the U.S. come together on foreign policy?
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode