The Pillar Podcast Ep. 242: Sing a new Hicks into being
Dec 20, 2025
The new archbishop of New York sparks spirited discussion as JD and Ed critique media narratives surrounding his appointment. They delve into the complexities of episcopal roles and dissect misconceptions about his political stance. The hosts celebrate Hicks's administrative strengths and emphasize the importance of evangelization over cultural small talk. They also reflect on the evolving expectations of bishops' public personas. Tune in for a blend of insightful commentary and festive cheer!
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Don't Reduce Bishops To Political Footnotes
- Media and commentators over-simplify episcopal appointments into political boxes like cabinet reshuffles.
- JD Flynn and Ed Condon warn this flattens three-dimensional people and decisions into partisan narratives.
Appointment Followed Practical Legal Preparations
- The New York appointment followed financial steps to resolve abuse litigation, not a sudden personnel purge.
- Bishop Hicks' selection came after the archdiocese arranged funds for a universal mediation with victims.
Hicks Seen As Competent Administrator
- Bishop Hicks is respected by many U.S. bishops and seen as competent in governance.
- His work as vicar general in Chicago suggests administrative skill alongside pastoral fidelity.