COJ #47 - Judge Newman Isn’t Playing Games - Team Murdaugh Gets Knocked Down
Sep 19, 2023
auto_awesome
Judge Clifton Newman and S.C. Prosecutor Creighton Waters tackle the South Carolina hearings for Alex Murdaugh, Cory Fleming, and Russell Laffitte. Interesting topics include Fleming's unexpected 10-year sentence, Murdaugh's state trial date interfering with his federal prison plan, and the South Carolina Justice System's refusal to play the federal government's games. The podcast also discusses trends in criminal sentencing, jury tampering accusations, and an analysis of Judge Newman's performance in court.
Judge Newman's sentencing of Corey Fleming serves as a strong deterrent to other lawyers involved in criminal activities, showcasing the importance of accountability and punishment.
Judge Newman's refusal to defer to the federal government during the hearing highlights a shift in power dynamics and emphasizes the sovereignty of the state of South Carolina.
The unexpected severity of Corey Fleming's state court sentencing shatters his hopes of a shorter federal sentence, reinforcing the gravity of his offenses and sending a strong message about the consequences of his actions.
Deep dives
Judge Newman's Impactful Sentencing
During the recent hearing, Judge Newman delivered a poignant and impactful sentencing to Corey Fleming, calling his crimes unprecedented and unimaginable. This sentence serves as a strong deterrent to other lawyers who may consider criminal activities. The judge's refusal to defer to the federal government and his emphasis on the sovereignty of the state of South Carolina showcased a shift in power dynamics and demonstrated the importance of punishing the crime and maintaining accountability.
Dick Harpoutley's Losing Streak
Dick Harpoutley, Corey Fleming's lawyer, faced multiple setbacks during the hearing. His disrespectful behavior towards Judge Newman and his ineffective arguments showcased a decline in his legal prowess. Judge Newman's refusal to grant Dick's request for a delayed trial date put a dent in Corey's strategy, causing further frustration for Dick. This courtroom display highlighted the impact of Judge Newman's no-nonsense approach and the changing dynamics of the legal landscape in South Carolina.
Corey Fleming's Lengthy State Sentence
Corey Fleming's sentencing in state court left him with a hefty prison term of 125 years. The judge's decision to stack his sentences for the Satterfield Heist and the Pimbola Pinkney case revealed the severity of Corey's crimes. This unexpected outcome shattered Corey's hopes of a shorter federal sentence and forced him to face the reality of spending a significant portion of his life in prison. The contrast between his federal and state sentences exemplifies the consequences of his actions and sends a strong message about the gravity of his offenses.
Judge Newman delivers a strong sentence in the Corey Fleming case
In a significant turn of events, Judge Newman defied expectations and handed down a sentence that far surpassed what Corey Fleming's legal team anticipated. Despite the belief that the federal government would provide a lenient sentence, Judge Newman made it clear that he would not go easy on Corey. The judge sent a strong message by giving Corey a sentence that was nearly five times longer than what he received in federal court. This showed the tension between state and federal governments in South Carolina and revealed that Corey's strategy of relying on federal charges backfired.
Debbie Barbie Aries faces disappointment and consequences of misjudgment
Debbie Barbie Aries, part of Corey's legal team, experienced a visible shift in demeanor during the proceedings. Previously confident, she now appeared pale and uneasy as Judge Newman delivered a far more severe sentence than expected. The defense had mistakenly believed that Judge Newman and Judge Gurgle had communicated and that Corey's outcome would be favorable. However, the judge's actions clearly demonstrated that state court was not going to follow the leniency of federal court. The moment served as a reminder of the risks and consequences involved in misjudgments and the impact they can have on a client's fate.
Co-hosts Mandy Matney, Liz Farrell andEric Bland — unpack the seven hours in hearings that were held last week for South Carolina’s “Unholy Trinity” Alex Murdaugh, Cory Fleming and Russell Laffitte. Judge Clifton Newman and S.C. Prosecutor Creighton Waters show the federal government that they’re not playing games. Plus will Alex go through with his plan to plead guilty in front of U.S. District Court Judge Richard Gergel now that he has a state trial date?
Cory Fleming was sentenced to 10 years for the Satterfield heist and 10 years for what he did to Pamela Pinckney. He’ll ultimately serve less than 14 years for everything but this is still so much more than anyone thought he’d get … including Cory and his team. Alex Murdaugh was assigned his state court trial date, which interferes with his strategy of getting into federal prison. And the South Carolina Justice System made it CLEAR they weren’t playing the federal government’s games.
Needless to say, Liz, Eric and Mandy could NOT WAIT to record this week’s episode because of how much there was to talk about.
Luna Shark Premium members get some special conversations about trends in criminal sentencing and the jury tampering in which EB has entered the fray on behalf of 4 jurors. Premium members get our full discussions about the topics and even more content on lunasharkmedia.com. SUNscribe to our free email list to get alerts on bonus episodes, calls to action, new shows and updates. CLICK HERE to learn more: https://bit.ly/3KBMJcP
Luna Shark Premium Soak Up The Sun Members will get a special treat this Thursday at 7pm ET when we broadcast a special conversation between Mandy and Blood on Their Hands co-author Carolyn Murnick. It’ll be pre-recorded as Mandy and David plan to attend the federal hearing Thursday, but Carolyn and Mandy will be in the YouTube live chat to answer questions. All members will get access to the content slightly after the broadcast and chat. Blood on Their Hands arrives November 14th but pre-sales are soo important. Go to www.bloodontheirhandsbook.comto learn more. Stay tuned for a big announcement for all Premium Members who purchase a copy soon!
*The views expressed on the Cup of Justice bonus episodes do not constitute legal advice. Listeners desiring legal advice for any particular legal matter are urged to consult an attorney of their choosing who can provide legal advice based upon a full understanding of the facts and circumstances of their claim. The views expressed on the Cup of Justice episodes also do not express the views or opinions of Bland Richter, LLP, or its attorneys.
